Sep 172011
 

Before I started this blog, PZ Myers had been critical of “dictionary atheism”, for example:

Why are you an atheist? (2011-02-01)
You don’t really want to be like Ray Comfort, do you? (2011-02-06)
Oh, no, not that annoying dictionary atheist argument again! (2011-04-14)

Although I have sometimes commented at (old) Pharyngula, I kept out of that discussion. Things sometimes got heated.

Could it be that PZ Myers, outspoken advocate for clarity of thought, speech, and writing, communicator par excellence, has finally flipped, and forgotten how important it is to speak in a language that the audience can be expected to understand? Hasn’t he been getting enough bacon?

Now that I have my own blog I can express my own views without constraints on size or format. Then go on to see if they are in any way compatible with what PZ Myers or others say.

Things I have said

I say a number of times on my personal website (to which this blog is an adjunct):

“The only safe generalisation about atheists is “we do not believe that gods exist”.
(Plus logical consequences of this)”.

That sounds like a “Dictionary atheist” position, and I certainly derived that statement from a dictionary. I also say there:

“”Atheist” is a word that summarises my beliefs about gods. It doesn’t dictate my beliefs.
I don’t get my beliefs from a dictionary or from anyone else”.

Types of atheist

There are hundreds of millions of people in the world who don’t believe gods exist. (I won’t include children. We are not entitled to make claims about their beliefs, and any claims of their own are provisional). We can validly call these people “atheists”, just as we can validly call people without hair on their heads “bald”. It is a descriptive, non-judgmental word, and this use is compatible with dictionaries. Dictionaries don’t define words, they identify their use.

But if we stick a microphone under their noses, and ask them “do you believe in any god?“, we will get a vast range of answers. In order to make progress, I’ll identify two stereotypical answers:

  1. “Er, no, but I don’t spend time thinking about this, and I haven’t much to say”.
  2. “No – I’m an atheist!”

There is little we can say about the first person, other than “The only safe conclusion is: “they do not believe that gods exist”. (Plus logical consequences of this)“”. This person is a genuine “Dictionary atheist”, and we have no justification in drawing further conclusions. Neither should we criticise that person. We all let some things slip below our horizon: how many of us spend lots of time each day addressing the fact that 18 children die every minute?

There is a lot we can suspect about the second person! That is an answer from someone who has thought it through, and placed themselves into a clear category. And when an intelligent person places themselves into a category, they will probably have considered the consequences, and analysed their relationship with people outside that category. They are likely to have views about the relative privileges of their category and the rest.

With a high probability, that person is something like a secular humanist: unwilling to let people outside that category have political privileges, and living according to principles and values that are derived from being a human being, not from reading ancient texts. (I’m largely taking about myself, of course!)

Now we can express preferences about people who self-define as atheists. We can expect them to think things through, and if they haven’t, tell them to do so.

Discussion

I think that PZ Myers was only addressing the second person. The sort of person who comments on Pharyngula; the sort of person who attends an atheist conference. In particular, self-identifying atheists, as in his following statements:

[my emphasis throughout] “Everyone who is an atheist is so because of other, prior ideas. I’m not saying that there is one set of ideas that make for a True Atheist™, but rather that if you claim there are not, if you pose as someone who is an atheist simply because you don’t believe in gods, you are failing to consider your own philosophical foundations. Calling yourself a Dictionary Atheist is like taking pride in living an unexamined life. That’s it. And that’s what really annoys me, people who can’t recognize that there’s more to their atheism than blind acceptance of what a dictionary says.”

I empathise with Scote, here and here and here and here and here. Scote got flak for those statements, but was one of the few to get back to basics. We do need to distinguish between the different sorts of people who don’t believe in gods. And, (having spent much of my career reading and writing technical specifications), I believe we need to be clear about how we are using words and terms. Diplomats want to be able to give the illusion of more agreement than there actually is, in order to make progress. Politicians often hide behind ambiguity. But the rest of us don’t have to take these as precedents.

I think Skatje Myers had a pretty good position; I am registered as a Bright, and I am a paid-up member of the British Humanist Association and the National Secular Society. Some people are in danger of overloading the word “atheist” with things we want to be true about atheists. But if atheists overload the word, this gives theists an excuse to overload the word too.

There is no particular reason why an atheist should know a lot about science, or even take much interest in it. I have a degree in Mathematical Physics, and science books and magazines and websites and blogs provide much of my reading. But why should every other atheist share this passion? We are talking about non-belief in gods, not talking about all aspects of the nature of the universe. There are lots of reasons why people don’t believe, and they are not all driven by (say) evolution.

Some conclusions

Keep the dictionary to hand! But distinguish between what we can say about someone who we simply know is an atheist according to the dictionary, and what we want to be true about someone who self-identifies as an atheist. We can hold the latter to a higher standard.

That doesn’t mean we should be trying to expand the meaning of the word “atheist”. It currently has a pretty useful meaning. Instead, it means that we want self-identifying atheists to be more than “just” atheists. I suggest that target should not simply be an enhanced form of atheism, but “enlightenment“.

  91 Responses to “Dictionary atheism”

  1. buy pregabalin 75mg generic – lyrica ca lyrica 75mg ca

  2. order clomid 100mg pills – order clomid pill order zyrtec 5mg online

  3. order desloratadine 5mg – order claritin sale oral triamcinolone 10mg

  4. misoprostol 200mcg pills – prednisolone 5mg ca cheap levothyroxine without prescription

  5. viagra 100mg price – real viagra gabapentin for sale

  6. cialis overnight shipping usa – cheap cialis without prescription order cenforce generic

  7. diltiazem over the counter – order acyclovir 800mg without prescription generic acyclovir 400mg

  8. atarax over the counter – generic hydroxyzine 25mg crestor 10mg drug

  9. ezetimibe pill – domperidone 10mg uk order celexa 20mg pills

  10. real viagra – sildenafil for sale buy flexeril 15mg online

  11. viagra 100mg price – buy cialis tablets cheapest cialis online

  12. buy toradol online – generic toradol ozobax brand

  13. gloperba sale – cost gloperba strattera 25mg ca

  14. viagra online order – plavix 75mg over the counter cost clopidogrel 75mg

  15. order viagra online cheap – viagra 50mg without prescription purchase viagra generic

  16. order nexium 40mg pills – purchase phenergan generic order promethazine 25mg sale

  17. buy tadalafil online cheap – Cialis prices tadalafil canada

  18. modafinil 100mg price – cheap erectile dysfunction pills online where to buy ed pills

  19. isotretinoin 10mg drug – buy azithromycin 250mg generic zithromax buy online

  20. lasix online order – over the counter viagra sildenafil uk

  21. cialis 40mg without prescription – cialis 40mg pills sildenafil 100mg cheap

  22. tadalafil india – order losartan 25mg online warfarin pills

  23. dutasteride cost – brand tadalafil 5mg cialis daily

  24. viagra overnight delivery – us viagra cialis ca

  25. buy ed pills cheap – prednisone 40mg for sale generic prednisone 10mg

  26. isotretinoin 40mg drug – buy amoxicillin 500mg amoxil 500mg over the counter

  27. Wonderful views on that!

  28. oral lasix – lasix over the counter purchase azithromycin generic

  29. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here.
    The sketch is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish.

    nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you
    wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same
    nearly very often inside case you shield this increase.

  30. order doxycycline 200mg online cheap – chloroquine canada aralen generic

  31. Greetings from Carolina! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your website
    on my iphone during lunch break. I love the
    info you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home.
    I’m amazed at how quick your blog loaded on my cell phone ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, very good blog!

  32. You could certainly see your skills within the article you write.

    The world hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe.
    All the time follow your heart.

  33. purchasing cialis on the internet – order viagra 100mg generic order sildenafil 100mg generic

  34. provigil over the counter – purchase modafinil order viagra 50mg without prescription

  35. low cost ed pills – medications list cheap prednisone 40mg

  36. isotretinoin 40mg us – buy amoxicillin 500mg online cheap brand celecoxib

  37. tamsulosin pills – zofran for sale oral spironolactone

  38. order simvastatin 10mg for sale – best essay writing websites custom dissertation

  39. best online casino – best college paper writing service help writing research paper

  40. slots online – order finasteride pills ampicillin 250mg oral

  41. generic ciprofloxacin – cialis 20mg cost cialis 10mg cheap

  42. sildenafil 150 mg – buy prednisone 20mg sale order vardenafil generic

  43. Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s
    really informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels.
    I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be
    benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  44. I read this post completely regarding the comparison of most recent and preceding technologies, it’s awesome article.

  45. Have you ever considered about including a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is important and all. However imagine if you added some great visuals or
    videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is
    excellent but with pics and clips, this blog could definitely be one of the greatest in its field.
    Excellent blog!

  46. What’s up everyone, it’s my first go to see at this web page, and post is
    really fruitful for me, keep up posting these types of articles.

  47. I’m gone to inform my little brother, that he should also visit this web site on regular
    basis to get updated from latest reports.

  48. I have read so many content regarding the blogger
    lovers however this paragraph is really a pleasant article, keep
    it up.

  49. That’s an awesome point

  50. That’s a great point

  51. prednisolone 10mg usa – generic prednisolone order cialis pill

  52. clavulanate canada – order augmentin 375mg generic order cialis 5mg sale

  53. sulfamethoxazole cost – bactrim pill sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription

  54. order cephalexin 250mg generic – erythromycin cost order generic erythromycin 500mg

  55. buy generic fildena 50mg – buy stromectol stromectol ivermectin otc

  56. rhinocort usa – buy antabuse 250mg generic disulfiram price

  57. buy generic cefuroxime – cialis over the counter order cialis 5mg online

  58. order ampicillin for sale – order cipro 1000mg pills buy cialis 20mg without prescription

  59. buy generic amoxil – azithromycin 250mg us cheap vardenafil

  60. ivermectin cream uk – stromectol purchase levitra 10mg pill

  61. Watch the best Xvideos com videos, free movies, mobile xvideos,
    and download for on this tube https://t.me/xvideos_xvideo

  62. buy doxycycline 100mg – tadalafil cost tadalafil 5 mg tablet

  63. cheap tadalafil 20mg – tadalafil 10mg sale order provigil

  64. buy deltasone 5mg generic – deltasone 5mg cheap order isotretinoin generic

  65. amoxicillin 1000mg cost – purchase amoxil without prescription cost viagra 100mg

  66. order prednisolone 10mg – order viagra pills buy viagra 100mg without prescription

  67. order lasix sale – furosemide cheap generic stromectol for humans

  68. buy plaquenil generic – order hydroxychloroquine 400mg for sale baricitinib 2mg for sale

  69. glucophage 1000mg cost – order generic metformin buy norvasc for sale

  70. buy levitra online cheap – purchase pregabalin sale clomid 100mg drug

  71. order ventolin 2mg for sale – buy priligy 30mg online order generic dapoxetine 60mg

  72. synthroid 100mcg generic – triamcinolone 10mg over the counter hydroxychloroquine online order

  73. cialis 10mg oral – order cialis 5mg generic sildenafil 150mg cost

  74. diltiazem la diltiazem medication can you stop diltiazem abruptly what is medicine diltiazem is for .com.com

  75. neurontin lawsuit 2018 neurontin medicine increasing dose of neurontin for peripheral neuropathy what drugs should not be taken with gabapentin?

  76. deltasone over the counter – buying prednisone online amoxil 1000mg without prescription

  77. diltiazem online buy – prednisolone 10mg pills buy neurontin 100mg generic

  78. order generic furosemide 40mg – order doxycycline 200mg online cheap doxycycline drug

  79. viagra buy melbourne cialis online australia how long does viagra work for when will cialis go generic

  80. purchase cenforce online – stromectol order domperidone 10mg us

  81. Тор: Любовь и гром http://clck.ru/rbT4C Тор Любовь и гром online смотреть онлайн

  82. order viagra 150mg generic – sildenafil over counter tadalafil 40mg without prescription

  83. benadryl and albuterol albuterol 2.5 relion ventolin hfa inhaler 8g albuterol when pregnant

  84. rx zanaflex zanaflex 6 mg zanaflex side effects weight gain what is zanaflex 4my used for

  85. provigil 100mg ca – buy erectile dysfunction medication order budesonide pills

  86. isotretinoin over the counter – cost accutane 10mg order tetracycline 250mg

  87. how long does it take for levitra to work levitra compare levitra price goodrx levitra

  88. flexeril 15mg cost – colchicine canada inderal for sale

  89. cenforce 100 uses cenforce ebay how long does cenforce 100 take to work buy cenforce 150mg online

 Leave a Reply

Name required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

Email required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>