Sep 232011

The Independent has a review by Colin Tudge of “The Magic of Reality” by Richard Dawkins, illustrated by Dave McKean. (This review is also discussed at and Butterflies and Wheels).

Virtually every one of the very many comments, both in The Independent and at, criticises, and in fact generally condemns, this review. (I use the word “review” because it is in the “Reviews” section of The Independent, not because it is a genuine book review in any plausible sense). Quite right! It is a bizarre polemic, a rant against some aspect of either the book, or perhaps of Richard Dawkins himself or what he represents, that appears to exist only in the mind of Colin Tudge.

To try to understand Colin Tudge a bit better, I Googled for: “Colin Tudge” religion. This led me, on Google Books, directly to a chapter by Colin Tudge here: “The Pari Dialogues: Essays in Science, Religion, Society and the Arts” by F. David Peat. (Also at I’m confident it is the same Colin Tudge.

In this chapter called “Science, Religion, and Me Personally” by Colin Tudge, we see:

… “I don’t want to define religion in the usual ways. I don’t want to say as many do that religion is inveterately concerned with the “supernatural”. I certainly don’t want to say that it necessarily involves any particular God who can be named and who must be worshipped via particular rituals and ceremonies”. …

… “But if you take the view, as I do, that religion is and aspires to be the all-embracing narrative, the complete account of all that is and could and should be, then none of these common positions will do. Religion, the way I see it, embraces all formal disciplines, including science”. …

… “If the mind-matter idea does stand up, if indeed it is true, then it changes everything. Its implications for some of the core ideas of religion need thinking through but they seem intuitively obvious. It re-admits the idea of the intelligent Universe: the Universe that “knows” what it wants to be. … More broadly, it leads to the idea of the immanent God (the God who is ever-present in the Universe), as opposed to the transcendant god (its detached Creator and arbiter). It suggests that prayer, which to some extent may be seen as an attempt to influence events by thinking, might have a physical basis.” …

After this, his review of a book about science as a way of explaining the universe, which also mentions religion in the context of supernatural myths, could be expected to be incomprehensible to most of us! He is pretty well defining his own esoteric language for talking about science and religion.

More Colin Tudge articles about “science versus religion”:

Microscopes have no morals (Guardian): …  “The continuing fight is an anachronism. It is rooted in misunderstanding both of religion and (oddly, since it is fought by some outstanding scientists) of science. It is often said that science answers “how” questions while religion asks “why”, but that is simplistic. The greater point lies in their scope. Religion, properly conceived, attempts to provide an account of all there is: the most complete narrative that human beings are capable of. Science, by contrast, is – as the British zoologist Sir Peter Medawar put the matter – “the art of the soluble”. It addresses only those questions that it occurs to scientists to ask, and feel they have a chance of answering.” …

The art of the soluble (Guardian): … “Atkins and Dawkins are prominent scientists – Dawkins one of the most original theorists of our age. But on matters of theology their arguments are a disgrace: assertive without substance; demanding evidence while offering none; staggeringly unscholarly.” …

Colin Tudge repeatedly quotes Sir Peter Medawar: “Science is the art of the soluble”. Does he hold religion in esteem because he thinks it is somehow “the art of the insoluble”?

  91 Responses to “Silly review by Colin Tudge of “The Magic of Reality””

  1. order lyrica 150mg without prescription – lyrica for sale purchase lyrica pills

  2. clomiphene over the counter – buy clomiphene pill cetirizine 5mg without prescription

  3. buy clarinex 5mg sale – claritin pill order triamcinolone 4mg pills

  4. generic cytotec – prednisolone 10mg us oral synthroid 150mcg

  5. sildenafil 50mg for sale – sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription buy gabapentin 800mg for sale

  6. cialis 40mg without prescription – order cialis 5mg online cenforce over the counter

  7. order generic diltiazem 180mg – acyclovir pills order zovirax 800mg without prescription

  8. buy generic hydroxyzine – purchase atarax pills buy generic rosuvastatin 10mg

  9. zetia order – buy ezetimibe 10mg without prescription celexa for sale online

  10. buy sildenafil 50mg for sale – price viagra buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg online cheap

  11. cheap sildenafil 150mg – order cialis 20mg online cheap tadalafil 40mg canada

  12. buy toradol sale – oral toradol 10mg ozobax price

  13. colchicine pills – order colchicine strattera 25mg oral

  14. sildenafil 100mg for sale – sildenafil 50mg over the counter order clopidogrel 75mg generic

  15. viagra 100mg brand – buy sildenafil 100mg sildenafil pills 150mg

  16. nexium online – cheap phenergan purchase promethazine online cheap

  17. cialis for men – Buy discount cialis tadalafil order

  18. purchase modafinil for sale – real online canadian pharmacy fda approved over the counter ed pills

  19. order isotretinoin pills – accutane uk purchase zithromax sale

  20. furosemide 100mg ca – furosemide 40mg brand viagra 50mg canada

  21. order tadalafil 10mg online cheap – order tadalafil 5mg online cheap sildenafil us

  22. order cialis 40mg sale – losartan 25mg over the counter brand coumadin

  23. order topamax 200mg generic – order imitrex 50mg pill imitrex 25mg generic

  24. order avodart 0.5mg without prescription – generic dutasteride tadalafil 40mg pills

  25. order viagra 150mg pills – viagra price cialis 20

  26. buy erectile dysfunction meds – prednisone 20mg pill order prednisone sale

  27. buy generic accutane 20mg – order generic amoxil 250mg amoxil canada

  28. cost lasix 100mg – furosemide 40mg drug order generic azithromycin 250mg

  29. I didn’t know that.

  30. order doxycycline without prescription – hydroxychloroquine brand chloroquine without prescription

  31. Everyone loves it when people get together
    and share opinions. Great blog, continue the good work!

  32. It’s genuinely very difficult in this busy life to listen news on Television, so I only use web for that purpose, and obtain the latest news.

  33. It’s amazing to pay a visit this web site and reading the views of
    all colleagues concerning this post, while I am also keen of
    getting knowledge.

  34. I have read so many articles regarding the blogger lovers except this piece of writing
    is genuinely a fastidious article, keep it up.

  35. Excellent blog here! Also your site so much up
    very fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your
    associate link on your host? I want my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  36. Quality posts is the main to attract the viewers to visit the site,
    that’s what this web site is providing.

  37. What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this site on a regular basis, this site is in fact pleasant and the people are truly sharing
    pleasant thoughts.

  38. This article gives clear idea designed for the new users of blogging, that actually how to do
    blogging and site-building.

  39. Your style is unique compared to other folks I
    have read stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess
    I will just bookmark this blog.

  40. It’s really very complicated in this active life to listen news on Television, therefore I
    only use world wide web for that purpose, and take the
    most recent news.

  41. rx pharmacy online cialis – viagra for sale viagra 200mg

  42. buy modafinil sale – us viagra sales sildenafil citrate

  43. pills for erection – best ed drugs deltasone 5mg price

  44. order accutane 20mg online – amoxil cheap cost celecoxib 100mg

  45. brand tamsulosin 0.2mg – buy ondansetron 8mg without prescription cost spironolactone 100mg

  46. zocor 10mg tablet – valtrex price how to write a hiring letter

  47. casino slots – casino games online write my thesis

  48. real casino online – propecia brand order ampicillin 500mg sale

  49. buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg pill – buy cipro pills buy tadalafil 40mg online

  50. viagra medication – generic viagra 150mg what is vardenafil used for

  51. I’ve been browsing on-line greater than three
    hours nowadays, yet I never discovered any fascinating article like yours.
    It is pretty price sufficient for me. Personally, if all website owners
    and bloggers made good content material as you probably did, the
    web will likely be much more helpful than ever before.

  52. Heya fantastic blog! Does running a blog such as this require
    a large amount of work? I have absolutely no understanding of coding but I was hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyhow,
    if you have any recommendations or tips for new blog owners please share.
    I know this is off topic nevertheless I just wanted
    to ask. Thank you!

  53. Very good info. Lucky me I recently found your website
    by chance (stumbleupon). I have bookmarked it for later!

  54. Hello there, You’ve done an excellent job. I
    will certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends.
    I’m sure they’ll be benefited from this site.

  55. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It actually was once a entertainment account it.

    Look complicated to far brought agreeable from you!

    However, how can we keep in touch?

  56. Why is it I always really feel like you do?

  57. order augmentin for sale – tadalafil cialis buy tadalafil 5mg pill

  58. buy trimethoprim generic – buy sildenafil 50mg pill sildenafil 100mg pill

  59. cephalexin 250mg uk – cleocin oral erythromycin 500mg oral

  60. order fildena 50mg without prescription – fildena 100mg us stromectol 3mg tablets

  61. budesonide nasal spray – order rhinocort generic disulfiram 250mg price

  62. cefuroxime 500mg without prescription – purchase cefuroxime online tadalafil for sale online

  63. order ampicillin 500mg sale – cialis 10mg sale cheap cialis generic

  64. amoxil price – azithromycin online buy levitra 20mg cheap

  65. stromectol 12mg online – levitra 10mg ca vardenafil 10mg cheap

  66. order doxycycline without prescription – order generic doxycycline buy cialis 20mg pills

  67. tadalafil over counter – modafinil 100mg pill buy provigil 100mg generic

  68. prednisone 40mg us – cheap ed drugs isotretinoin price

  69. order amoxil pill – amoxicillin 250mg uk sildenafil fast shipping

  70. prednisolone uk – purchase gabapentin for sale purchase sildenafil pills

  71. buy furosemide 100mg for sale – oral lasix ivermectin 12mg without prescription

  72. order hydroxychloroquine online – baricitinib drug order baricitinib 4mg generic

  73. levitra generic – clomiphene 50mg brand clomid 50mg over the counter

  74. albuterol pills – order ventolin 2mg generic dapoxetine cost

  75. oral synthroid 100mcg – order triamcinolone without prescription order hydroxychloroquine 400mg sale

  76. buy tadalafil 5mg online – cheap cialis 20mg sildenafil 150mg us

  77. oral prednisone 5mg – prednisone prescription buy amoxil 1000mg pills

  78. diltiazem 180mg oral – prednisolone 10mg price order neurontin pills

  79. lasix 40mg for sale – buy doxycycline pill buy doxycycline 100mg pills

  80. I am writing to let you understand what a helpful discovery my cousin’s child encountered visiting your blog. She learned plenty of pieces, including what it is like to have an amazing teaching character to let many people easily fully understand some advanced issues. You undoubtedly did more than visitors’ desires. I appreciate you for imparting the practical, trustworthy, revealing and easy tips about this topic to Lizeth.

  81. purchase cenforce without prescription – rosuvastatin generic order domperidone

  82. cheap viagra tablets – sildenafil citrate 50 mg order tadalafil 20mg for sale

  83. My wife and i got so delighted Michael managed to finish up his basic research from your precious recommendations he gained out of your blog. It is now and again perplexing just to happen to be giving for free secrets that many the others have been trying to sell. And we know we have the blog owner to appreciate because of that. The type of illustrations you have made, the straightforward website navigation, the relationships you will help promote – it’s got everything terrific, and it’s really facilitating our son in addition to the family do think that situation is satisfying, which is certainly especially mandatory. Thanks for everything!

  84. Thank you a lot for providing individuals with a very nice chance to read articles and blog posts from this blog. It’s usually so cool and full of a good time for me and my office colleagues to search your blog on the least 3 times in one week to study the latest secrets you will have. And of course, I am also certainly fascinated considering the cool methods served by you. Some 4 points in this posting are undeniably the most suitable we have ever had.

  85. modafinil 100mg price – prednisone 20mg oral rhinocort pills

  86. Amazing issues here. I am very happy to look your article.

    Thanks a lot and I’m taking a look ahead to contact you.
    Will you please drop me a mail?

  87. I wanted to post you this tiny remark just to say thank you yet again relating to the striking advice you have shared in this case. This has been wonderfully generous with you to allow openly precisely what a few individuals might have advertised as an e-book to help make some profit for their own end, even more so now that you might well have done it in the event you wanted. Those creative ideas as well worked to become fantastic way to understand that other people online have the identical desire really like my very own to know more and more on the subject of this issue. I’m certain there are some more enjoyable occasions ahead for individuals that view your blog.

  88. Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily terrific possiblity to read critical reviews from this web site. It really is so terrific and as well , full of amusement for me personally and my office fellow workers to visit your web site more than thrice per week to read through the fresh guides you have. Not to mention, I’m also usually fulfilled concerning the amazing principles you give. Some 2 tips on this page are truly the best we have ever had.

  89. I’m also commenting to let you be aware of what a remarkable discovery my cousin’s princess went through using yuor web blog. She picked up some details, which include what it’s like to have an amazing helping heart to get others just understand several problematic subject areas. You undoubtedly did more than my expected results. Thanks for displaying these necessary, safe, explanatory and in addition fun thoughts on your topic to Mary.

  90. order isotretinoin 10mg sale – cheap amoxil 1000mg order generic tetracycline

 Leave a Reply

Name required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

Email required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>