Sep 262011

I recently posted Silly review by Colin Tudge of “The Magic of Reality”. In there I quoted from an older article of his: Microscopes have no morals (Guardian, 2003):

It is often said that science answers “how” questions while religion asks “why”, but that is simplistic. The greater point lies in their scope. Religion, properly conceived, attempts to provide an account of all there is: the most complete narrative that human beings are capable of. Science, by contrast, is – as the British zoologist Sir Peter Medawar put the matter – “the art of the soluble”. It addresses only those questions that it occurs to scientists to ask, and feel they have a chance of answering.

Perhaps he has since changed his views, although other quotes from there suggest not. But that is irrelevant; I am not writing this article to further criticise Colin Tudge, but to refute the sentiments in the above quote, thus:

  • The scope of science is expanding what we think and talk about, and increasingly encroaching on what was once the scope of religion.
  • The scope of religion is shrinking as science replaces parts of it, and diminishing as a proportion of what we can now plausibly discuss.

The expanding scope of science

What are the boundaries of science? What topics will it never be able to tackle? I often say “sooner or later, science works”. But will there be a time, or a topic, where this isn’t true? I don’t know!

But one thing is pretty clear: we cannot yet rule anything out. And without confidence that a particular topic can never be handled by science, we might as well just try it anyway! If we can’t make progress within (say) the next 1000 years, perhaps we will have to admit defeat, and let a vastly more capable species eventually descended from us tackle it.

Can science say anything about the existence of god(s)?

  • Science can state confidently that certain types of god don’t exist, that certain other types of god are unnecessary, and that certain things supposedly done by god(s) were not.

Among the hard tasks are finding the right questions, and then identifying the right tools (in the most general sense) to answer them. Science often has to approach a topic from an unexpected direction, not from the direction of earlier, poorer, questions.

Science is now capable of giving us the “magical” or poetic narratives we enjoy.

The shrinking scope of religion

I won’t use Colin Tudge’s esoteric redefinition of religion (as in: “Religion, properly conceived …”). Obviously, by redefining religion and science to a point where religious people and scientists wouldn’t understand the words any more, the title of this article could be reversed. I’ll try to use the words in a way that a typical audience would understand.

Holy books talk about such things as: the issues of the day when they were written; the nature of the universe; and how people should think and behave. Each of these separately ceases to be relevant over centuries, even if they ever were relevant.

The issues of the day

When we treat history as a scientific-type (rigorous, rational) discipline, rather than a fanciful narrative, even the “issues of the day” of religious texts are transformed. The issues may have been real to a sub-population, but their context typically reduces. Moses probably didn’t exist. The exodus never happened. They were myths to provide a back-drop for inspiring hope in a beleaguered society. Adam and Eve didn’t exist, so they didn’t sin, so we haven’t inherited their sin, so Jesus didn’t die for our sins. If he existed, he died a pointless death.

The nature of the universe

Needless to say, everything to do with the nature of the observable, detectable, measurable, predictable, universe has been pretty well superseded by science. Certainly the scientific process/method justifies the statement “sooner or later, science works”. And “other ways of knowing”, including (but not confined to) religion, can’t establish credibility. The expansion of our vision of the universe, hence of what it is that a “way of knowing” has to explain, is driven by science. (The Pope doesn’t have a “hot-line to Jesus”! And neither does anyone else, or it would be religion, not science, that pushed at the boundaries of our knowledge).

A problem with those “other ways of knowing” is that people are entitled to ask of them “why should we believe these results?” Religions can only go so far with an attitude of Evidence? I don’t have to show you any stinking evidence!

I am an engineer, not a practicing scientist. (Although my degree was in Mathematical Physics, and I have been reading about science at least weekly, and more recently daily, for decades). For me, the power of science is that I have been able to exploit it, as technology, and help build things with it that work. In other words, “sooner or later, the products of science work”. The same does not apply to “other ways of knowing”.

How people should think and behave

This is the topic of morality. And Religions are incompetent at morality! Here are the implications:

  • Religions create poor moral codes and/or let their moral codes become out-of-date
  • Religions believe they have good moral codes, and so promote them and often try to enforce them
  • Religions under-estimate moral codes from other sources

The 10 Commandments long ago became obsolescent. They are pretty useless in the 21st Century. But they were never a competent moral code.  (See also:  What’s Wrong With The Ten Commandments?)

Sam Harris is attempting in effect to start a science of morality with his book The Moral Landscape. There are two different but related effects:

  • religions are losing credibility about their views on morality;
  • and science is independently beginning to tackle the topic.

Religious people who take their holy books seriously become more separated from the real world decade by decade.  They should accept that Holy books need expiry dates. This needn’t kill religions, but it identifies their scope within our complex world:  Religions are hobbies.

“It’s only the Bible; it’s not gospel!”

Here is what Edgar Guest could have said about science:

Somebody said that it couldn’t be done,
But he with a chuckle replied
That “maybe it couldn’t,” but he would be one
Who wouldn’t say so till he’d tried.
So he buckled right in with the trace of a grin
On his face. If he worried he hid it.
He started to sing as he tackled the thing
That couldn’t be done, and he did it.

  61 Responses to “The expanding scope of science; the shrinking scope of religion”

  1. buy pregabalin generic – purchase pregabalin without prescription cheap lyrica

  2. buy clomid online – cost clomid 50mg zyrtec 10mg drug

  3. desloratadine generic – desloratadine order online buy aristocort 10mg for sale

  4. buy misoprostol pills – prednisolone 40mg without prescription synthroid oral

  5. viagra 150mg us – us viagra sales buy gabapentin 100mg for sale

  6. usa pharmacy cialis – oral cenforce cenforce 50mg oral

  7. diltiazem online buy – diltiazem 180mg cost acyclovir 400mg oral

  8. purchase atarax online cheap – buy crestor 20mg online cheap purchase rosuvastatin online

  9. ezetimibe 10mg usa – purchase domperidone sale buy celexa 40mg sale

  10. buy viagra 100mg without prescription – order lisinopril 2.5mg pills buy flexeril 15mg

  11. viagra 100mg usa – sildenafil over counter buy cialis 40mg

  12. buy toradol 10mg without prescription – toradol oral buy baclofen 25mg online cheap

  13. colchicine ca – colchicine pill purchase strattera generic

  14. buy sildenafil pill – order sildenafil 50mg without prescription buy sildenafil generic

  15. esomeprazole 20mg sale – esomeprazole online buy buy promethazine generic

  16. buying cialis cheap – cialis india tadalafil 5 mg tablet

  17. buy modafinil 100mg generic – buy modafinil 100mg sexual dysfunction

  18. brand isotretinoin 40mg – purchase amoxicillin generic buy zithromax

  19. cheap furosemide 40mg – generic lasix 40mg viagra 50mg pill

  20. cialis tablet – buy tadalafil 40mg pill buy viagra 50mg online

  21. order tadalafil 10mg sale – cozaar cheap purchase coumadin generic

  22. topamax 200mg without prescription – topiramate 200mg without prescription sumatriptan 25mg us

  23. avodart price – purchase tadalafil online cheap cialis australia

  24. viagra us – buy generic viagra 150mg genuine cialis

  25. buy pills for erectile dysfunction – prednisone 5mg usa prednisone 5mg without prescription

  26. isotretinoin 20mg ca – amoxicillin for sale buy amoxil 1000mg without prescription

  27. lasix 100mg price – buy zithromax 250mg generic azithromycin 250mg drug

  28. Wonderful views on that!

  29. doxycycline order – order hydroxychloroquine generic chloroquine order

  30. It’s really a nice and helpful piece of info. I’m glad that you just shared this helpful information with us.

    Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for

  31. I visited many web sites but the audio quality for audio songs
    current at this site is truly marvelous.

  32. Keep on writing, great job!

  33. Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future.

    A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  34. Hello i am kavin, its my first time to commenting anywhere, when i read this post i thought i could also create comment
    due to this brilliant paragraph.

  35. Hi everybody, here every person is sharing these experience, therefore
    it’s fastidious to read this web site, and I used to pay a quick visit
    this website everyday.

  36. Hello, i feel that i saw you visited my web site so i got
    here to return the choose?.I’m trying to find things to
    improve my web site!I guess its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

  37. You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation however I in finding this
    matter to be really one thing that I feel I’d never understand.
    It sort of feels too complicated and very large for me.
    I’m looking forward to your next put up, I’ll try to get the
    dangle of it!

  38. Hi would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re working with?
    I’m planning to start my own blog soon but I’m having a hard time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique.
    P.S My apologies for being off-topic but I had to ask!

  39. It’s not my first time to visit this web site, i am visiting this site dailly
    and take fastidious facts from here daily.

  40. cheap tadalafil without prescription – Buy cialis online cheap sildenafil 100 mg

  41. cost provigil – female viagra cvs buy viagra 100mg for sale

  42. can you buy ed pills online – buy canadian drugs buy deltasone 5mg

  43. accutane 20mg brand – amoxicillin 250mg for sale celebrex 200mg uk

  44. tamsulosin 0.4mg brand – order aldactone 100mg aldactone medication

  45. buy zocor 10mg generic – speechwriters buy my essay

  46. real money online casinos usa – help with term papers buy essay paper

  47. online casino real money no deposit – ampicillin uk buy ampicillin without prescription

  48. cipro drug – buy cipro 500mg online cheap order tadalafil pill

  49. order viagra 50mg for sale – viagra 100mg ca vardenafil tablets 20 mg

  50. Every weekend i used to pay a visit this site, as i want enjoyment, as this this web site
    conations actually good funny stuff too.

  51. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
    Did you design this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
    Plz respond as I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to find out
    where u got this from. cheers

  52. I got this site from my buddy who shared with me regarding this
    website and now this time I am visiting this site and reading very informative content

  53. I’d like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in penning this website.
    I really hope to view the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future
    as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has motivated
    me to get my own, personal website now ;)

  54. order prednisolone 10mg sale – order generic cialis 10mg cialis discount

  55. That’s a great point

  56. buy augmentin 625mg – order augmentin 625mg pills buy tadalafil 10mg without prescription

  57. order bactrim 480mg generic – order sildenafil 50mg generic sildenafil drug

  58. buy cephalexin generic – erythromycin online erythromycin 500mg over the counter

  59. order sildenafil pill – generic fildena 100mg generic ivermectin

  60. budesonide over the counter – budesonide generic disulfiram 500mg tablet

 Leave a Reply

Name required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

Email required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>