Oct 062012

I have said a number of times:

“Islam, identified by the Koran and Hadith, is incompatible with Universal Human Rights and incompatible with the 21st Century”

It is worth showing more evidence for this claim.

Islam and Universal Human Rights – freedom of expression

I’ll use quotes from a recent (5th October) article from a Pakistan newspaper:

“Leaders of religious parties at an All Parties Conference (APC) have demanded of the rulers of the Muslim countries to move a resolution in the United Nations (UN) for an international legislation against the blasphemers….

“A communiqué issued on the occasion … demanded a review of clause 3 of article 1 of UN charter to remove the insult of religions and religious ideals from the scope of freedom of expression and declare it a global crime.”

That clause of the UN Charter states:

(The Purposes of the United Nations are …. 3)  “To achieve international co-operation in solving international problems of an economic, social, cultural, or humanitarian character, and in promoting and encouraging respect for human rights and for fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to race, sex, language, or religion

To identify the “scope of freedom of expression” which they want to restrict, see the Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (one of the most important documents of the 20th Century):

Article 19 – “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.”

Needless to say, Article 19 is reasonably compatible with the US Bill of Rights (the 1st Amendment) and the European Convention on Human Rights (Article 10). It is compatible with rights in many other nations too.

The Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam (officially supported by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation) makes it clear in Article 22 that Shariah (Islamic Law) restricts the freedom to express opinions:

(a) Everyone shall have the right to express his opinion freely in such manner as would not be contrary to the principles of the Shari’ah.
(b) Everyone shall have the right to advocate what is right, and propagate what is good, and warn against what is wrong and evil according to the norms of Islamic Shari’ah.
(c) Information is a vital necessity to society. It may not be exploited or misused in such a way as may violate sanctities and the dignity of Prophets, undermine moral and ethical values or disintegrate, corrupt or harm society or weaken its faith.

In effect, those “Leaders of religious parties at an All Parties Conference” (above) are proposing that part of Shariah should become global law! See also Defamation of religion and the United Nations.

Islam and Universal Human Rights – other rights

Here are some other incompatibilities between Articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Islam:

Article 1 – “All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights” ….
Cairo Declaration, Articles 1 & 6 – Women don’t have equal rights.
And see Muslim women in the Olympics

Article 7 – “All are equal before the law” ….
Qur’an – Husbands can sometimes beat their wives (but not vice-versa) [4:34]. Women are at most half as reliable in court [2:282]. Women only deserve half the inheritance of their brothers [4:11, 4:176]. (There are other inequalities in Shariah that are not in the Qur’an or the Cairo Declaration).

Article 18 – Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief ….
General – Apostasy is normally considered to be a serious matter, and in some jurisdictions it is a crime with serious punishments.

Article 26 – (1) Everyone has the right to education. Education shall be free, at least in the elementary and fundamental stages. Elementary education shall be compulsory. Technical and professional education shall be made generally available and higher education shall be equally accessible to all on the basis of merit.
General – In practice equality of education for girls and women is often breached in Islamic states. However, arguably this is not formally part of Islam, but instead is a cultural problem that survives because women are not equal according to Islam.

Islam and the 21st Century

The basis for incompatibility is summarised in Tropicana Pineapple Juice called Mohammed. Is it blasphemy?:

“There are about 7 billion people in the world. 1000s of gods are worshipped. 1000s of religions are practised. 1000s of contradictory ideologies are espoused. In a world of global communications, it is probably impossible to say or show anything significant that someone somewhere won’t get upset about. It is obviously impossible to prevent those words and images being published.

“The onus is on people who disagree with them to take appropriate action if they are not to be upset or distressed. Except for personal attacks (which are not what I’m talking about here), people typically get upset for one of 2 reasons: because they have chosen to be upset; or because they have been brought up (perhaps indoctrinated) to be upset. For their sake, and for the sake of their children, they should choose not to be upset, and should not indoctrinate their children to be upset.”

Although blasphemy is sometimes claimed by atheists to be a “victimless crime”, it typically originates not to protect god(s) but to protect a fragile society from fragmentation. From Wikipedia:

“Some Islamic scholars point out it is important to understand the hadith in its proper historical context: it was written when the nascent Muslim community in Medina was fighting for its existence, and the enemies of Islam encouraged rebellion and discord within the community. At that time, any defection would have had serious consequences for the Muslims, and the hadith may well be about treason, rather than just apostasy.”

And the same applied to English blasphemy laws protecting Christianity. These laws were past their “use-by date” and have now been removed.  This need to move on from historical attitudes is covered in Holy books need expiry dates. The holy texts of Islam passed their “use-by date” in the 18th Century during the Age of Enlightenment. Islam was really incompatible with the 19th and 20th Centuries as well as the 21st Century.

Christianity has had hundreds of years to adapt itself to modernity. Islamic states are experiencing modernity being thrust upon them as a package: the global communication capability they want brings with it communications they don’t want. This isn’t their only conflict with modernity: those states have in the past been called a “science desert”. There is sometimes suspicion that “Western-style” evidence-based reasoning is incompatible with their conviction that they are custodians of the final and eternal word of Allah. And one group claiming responsibility for some of the violence stated that democracy is incompatible with Islam, because only Allah can make laws.

Islam versus Muslims

This article is about “Islam”, not about “most Muslims”. Individual Muslims may be far more enlightened than Islam itself, of course! This is potentially true where they are integrated minorities in non-Islamic states and are free to cherry-pick the less medieval, intolerant and barbaric bits. (See also Should modern Muslims re-brand Islam?).

All of us are pulled in many directions, by our upbringing, culture, education, family and community pressures, national values and laws, and our own analysis. The major religions had their roots in pre-enlightenment times, and this results in a direct pull (via personal beliefs arising from upbringing) and ongoing indirect pulls (via some in the family and community) towards unenlightened attitudes. But many Christians and Muslims overcome most of these these pulls and have a world-view compatible with the 21st Century. (“Most” but not “all” – they still believe without evidence in their particular god!)

If Islam and the 21st Century are to be compatible, there are 2 main approaches:

  1. Islam adapts itself to the 21st Century by adopting Enlightenment values and Universal Human Rights
  2. The 21st Century adapts to Islam by globally adopting Shariah at the expense of Enlightenment values

Which is it to be? Many Muslims want global Shariah, starting with Shariah in their current country. The trick for the rest of us is to spread the influence of enlightened attitudes widely and never give ground to Shariah. See The war for enlightenment.

Further reading

  3,544 Responses to “Islam is incompatible with Universal Human Rights & the 21st Century”

  1. [url=http://nolvadextamoxifen.monster/]tamoxifen cost in mexico[/url]

  2. [url=http://viagramedicationforsale.quest/]female viagra brand name[/url]

  3. [url=http://bestcialistabsforsale.quest/]cialis cost australia[/url]

  4. [url=http://bestcialis10mglowcost.quest/]where to purchase cialis[/url]

  5. [url=http://flomax.today/]where to get flomax[/url]

  6. [url=http://buyanafranil.com/]anafranil purchase online[/url]

  7. [url=http://prednisonedeltasone.monster/]5 mg prednisone daily[/url]

  8. pregabalin 75mg tablet – buy pregabalin 150mg for sale pregabalin 75mg pill

  9. dark web market list drug markets onion [url=https://wworldmarket.link/ ]bitcoin dark web [/url]

  10. cartel marketplace url darknet market comparison [url=https://market-darknet.com/ ]tor dark web [/url]

  11. silkkitie market white house market url [url=https://blackmarketblock.com/ ]how to get on darknet market [/url]

  12. torrez market televend darknet market [url=https://darknetmarketexpert.com/ ]darkmarket link [/url]

  13. clomiphene 100mg cheap – zyrtec 5mg tablet purchase zyrtec pills

  14. how to buy from the darknet markets current darknet markets

  15. reddit darknet market noobs hydra link

  16. darknet market onion links black market drugs

  17. televend darknet market darkc0de

  18. alphabay darknet market asap link

  19. darknet market list 2022 cartel link

  20. how to use darknet markets dark market url

  21. best darknet market 2022 incognito link

  22. new darknet market reddit darkweb market

  23. best darknet market australia dark web market list

  24. [url=http://onlineviagra50mgprice.monster/]make viagra at home[/url]

  25. wall street market darknet reddit hydra market darknet

  26. how to create a darknet market hansa darknet market

  27. wall street market darknet reddit white house market url

  28. purchase desloratadine for sale – purchase desloratadine for sale order aristocort 4mg pills

  29. darknet empire market drug market

  30. reddit darknet market list 2022 daeva market

  31. new darknet market reddit darkc0de market

  32. incognito market link darkc0de

  33. wall street market darknet reddit versus darknet market

  34. the wall street market darknet versus link

  35. versus project market darknet vice city market

  36. best darknet market 2021 darkc0de

  37. how to access darknet markets tor market links

  38. what is the darknet market daeva market url

  39. darknet markets 2021 reddit dark market url

  40. best darknet market for steroids torrez darknet market

  41. darknet wallstreet market darkmarket list

  42. как зайти на гидру гидра вход

  43. biggest darknet market 2021 dark web link

  44. darknet market list reddit darkc0de market

  45. wall street market darknet reddit darknet market links

  46. darknet markets onion address liberty market url

  47. wall street market darknet review darknet drug links

  48. dream market darknet url cypher market

  49. how to access the darknet market monopoly market link

  50. spurdomarket darknet market tor2door link

  51. misoprostol drug – cheap levothyroxine sale purchase levothyroxine pills

  52. what is the darknet market darknet markets

  53. darknet market noobs bible Silkkitie link

  54. darknet markets onion address darknet market

  55. reddit darknet markets 2022 tor2door link

  56. how to buy from the darknet markets liberty darknet market

  57. wall street market darknet link dream market darknet

  58. wall street market darknet link daeva market link

  59. dark web drug marketplace white house link

  60. grams darknet market search engine archetyp link

  61. the wall street market darknet vice city link

  62. are there any darknet markets left agora darknet market

  63. гидра зеркало hydra onion зеркало

  64. как зайти на гидру гидра шишки

  65. darknet wall street market cartel link

  66. dream market darknet link archetyp link

  67. tor2door market darknet daeva link

  68. darknet dream market reddit hydra market

  69. silkkitie darknet market daeva link

  70. empire market darknet stats torrez market link

  71. гидра сайт ссылка магазин гидра

  72. darknet markets 2021 reddit bohemia market

  73. white house market darknet cannahome link

  74. best darknet market 2022 reddit white house market

  75. how to create a darknet market televend market darknet

  76. black market prescription drugs for sale cartel link

  77. white house market darknet cannahome link

  78. darknet markets 2021 reddit archetyp market

  79. wall street market darknet link versus project link

  80. hydra onion оффициальный сайт hydra onion

  81. reddit darknet market list 2021 alphabay market url

  82. reddit darknet market list 2021 alphabay market link

  83. black market prescription drugs for sale bohemia darknet market

  84. darknet markets onion address darkweb markets

  85. darknet wallstreet market vice city link

  86. reddit darknet market list 2022 darknet markets 2022

  87. versus project market darknet monero darknet markets

  88. sildenafil mail order – order gabapentin 100mg pills neurontin 600mg pill

  89. grams darknet market search darknet market ddos

  90. how to get to darknet market asap darknet market

  91. russian darknet market daeva link

  92. dark web drug marketplace tor market url