Dec 312012

Original suggestion on Twitter

Here are the comments I promised. (I’ve provided a review at too).

This book is unashamedly a polemic rather than an unemotional analysis. This provides the emotional energy to carry the topic, and no doubt resonates with many young people today. It is a rallying cry for “something must be done!” (And perhaps “heads must roll!”)

But more analysis would have revealed that things are not always as stated, and seeking solutions (rather than debating problems) needs a more focused identification of underlying causes so that they can be fixed. The book is better at casting blame (sometimes wrongly) towards the past than at proposing solutions for the future. (I’m speaking as someone who did a lot of analysis of social issues during my career and afterward).

“Jilted Generation: How Britain has Bankrupted its Youth”


The book talks of its generation being cast aside. The word typically means “loved then discarded”. Perhaps that it how it feels.

But was any other generation “loved but not discarded”? I think people in earlier generations had lower initial expectations and so didn’t feel such a loss whenever it was a case of “life’s a bitch and then you die”. This is a problem with any assumption that each generation will be better off than the previous one; why should people assume that? If the life-features of generations are a combination of trends + luck, then “regression to the mean” will typically make some life-features worse in the next generation!


“Generation” really only means much within a family. It is a poor way of talking about a set of people born over some 25  year period (or whatever). There is rarely a fully plausible definition of the generation, nor do all the identified people have much in common.

The generation of this book is the one born after September 1979, because that identifies those who had to pay more to go to university. For a minority of people that matters a lot. But nearly two-thirds of this generation didn’t go to university, so this distinguishing factor is irrelevant to them! This is also the generation of most Premier League footballers and their WAGS, and of most of the Olympians and Paralympians who are the British heroes feted in the recent New Year’s Honours list. Lots of people are fond of some of the members of this generation!


I was born in 1947. See where that lies on the graph below!

UK national debt as a proportion of GDP

It is nonsense to say (for example) that “children are born broke“! (Most people would find it hard to identify what impact the national debt has on their lives). Important questions include “how much interest is paid on the debt”, which in effect is a leakage of tax-payers’ money, and “how much does the size of the national debt constrain the policies of government”, (by internal or external forces), which could be policies relevant to any or all generations. To be fair, the book does discuss those.

“The Next Normal: An Unprecedented Look at Millennials Worldwide”

Viacom has conducted a world-wide survey about “[the Millennial population's] distinctive attitudes, behaviors and aspirations“  and published its (PDF) summary in November 2012. This Millennial population overlaps with the so-called “Jilted Generation”.

  • Question: On a scale of 1 to 10 where 10 equals extremely happy and 1 equals not at all happy, how happy would you say you are in general?
  • Answer: about 76% across the world, and about the same in the UK, responded within the range 7 to 10 inclusive.

Baby boom

The book makes some stereotypical statements about a baby-boom from about 1945 to about 1965. It modifies them, for example using a diagram from the Office of National Statistics to talk about a ‘first-wave baby boom’ between about 1945 to 1952, rising again only between the the years 1956 and 1965 in the ‘second-wave baby boom’. But the earlier spike was actually smaller, and the “second-wave” was from about 1955 to 1974: 1965 was the peak of a baby-boom, not the end of one! Later the book says “by the time the last of the baby boomers retire in 2030 …”. But once again that falsely assumes that 1965 was the end of the baby boom: the last of the 1955-1974 baby boomers will retire about 2040. See:

Accompanying these errors in the demographics is inconsistent blaming of the baby boomers (whoever they are!) For example:

“We know that our parents didn’t want it this way; we know that when they accepted the terms of their society they were only trying to do what was best for themselves and their families. But we also know that they could have done better if more of them had remembered that they weren’t just individuals but citizens too”.

What on Earth does “they could have done better if more of them had remembered that they weren’t just individuals but citizens too” mean? Assuming that this is supposed to be about me too, what should I have done that I didn’t do? What did I do that I shouldn’t have done? That statement is abstract waffle, not grounded in the real actions of real people living a real life. I suspect it is based somehow on the assumption that we had at the time at least the knowledge that the authors have with hindsight, plus our hands on the levers of power. Hardly any of us had such power, and none of us had such knowledge.


I found this one of the most interesting parts of the book. It has caused me to revise a statement I have made a number of times that only 1% of us had our hands on the levers of power. That is optimistic; I now think less than 0.1% of us did!

I now see that all government is an ongoing experiment! The situations that have to be catered for have never arisen in the same way before. There is no rule-book that is known to work. Prior ideologies were probably designed (perhaps only in theory) for previous cases. Much of the time, politicians, who don’t really understand one-another fully and haven’t got time to negotiate with everyone concerned, make things up as they go along. Arrogance (or impatience or ignorance) prevents the running of controlled experiments.

Furthermore, things that may have been easy to give are hard to take away later. It is almost impossible to make a fresh start with a particular topic, but instead “course corrections” (hopefully “corrections”!) are made to existing policies, and then sold as new initiatives. It looks like bad management, but the media and the public are partly to blame for this. “U turns” are condemned; programmes on which money has been spent tend to continue too long (the “sunk cost fallacy”).


In the late 1990s I was one of the business analysts studying the welfare state in preparation for potentially replacing its core IT systems. It was obvious to us that the benefits system was dysfunctional and vast simplification was needed. It was also obvious that it would never happen: to be even barely acceptable to voters and lobby-groups it would cost the Treasury lots more; and since the Treasury wouldn’t pay out, it would never be acceptable.

Then Ian Duncan Smith proposed the Universal Credit, which was exactly what we had known was needed! But it would surely still be impossible to get past the Treasury, and anything acceptable to them would fail with the electorate. Yet – it still survives (trimmed a bit), and hopefully will become law! It is the sort of “once in a lifetime” opportunity to sort out the mess resulting from incremental “politically acceptable” evolution that is needed more often. But it is nearly-impossible to achieve these, and typically a kludge gets added to a botch and interacts with a cock-up that has become embedded in society. (I am probably in a very small minority of people who are confident that we really do need the Universal Credit!)

Prospect theory tells us that the negative emotion of losing something is about twice the positive emotion of gaining it in the first place. Things that could have been omitted at first without too much fuss cannot be removed later without lots of fuss. Policy making can never be a purely rational activity, except with hindsight!

Housing & jobs & having children

Why lump housing, jobs, and children together? Because they all involve life-style choices, some of which make life harder for the people who make particular decisions.

Taking myself as a sample of one:
My sister and I lived with my parents in a small 3-bedroom council flat in a concrete council estate in Birmingham until I graduated. (I had 3 jobs in all during university to help my parents pay for my education). My chosen job was a long way away, so for the first year I lived with my parents at weekends then commuted to lodgings near my job, where I shared a bedroom with (initially) strangers during the week. (Once I had finished at university, my parents in their 40s could afford to buy their own house). Then for 6 years I shared rented houses with relative strangers, but with individual bedrooms. Then I stepped onto the housing ladder by buying (with a mortgage) a grotty 2-bedroom semi-detached bungalow on a grotty estate. My ladyfriend moved in with her daughter, and the three of us lived in those 2 bedrooms for several years until we moved up the housing ladder. After many years, we separated and I bought a cheaper house and became childfree (my preference) again. Every house was chosen to be near enough to my job as the latter moved around.

Some people want to live near where they were raised. Some people want to have children and bring them up in a “family house”. Some people struggle to find a suitable job. Sometimes these choices are inter-connected. The more constraints that are placed on the location and quality of houses the harder it becomes to satisfy all the constraints.

There is a theme in this book about being able to live near where people were brought up (even in the South-East!), and wanting a family but having to delay it until a family-house can be afforded.  While those are obviously desirable to those concerned, they are certainly not all necessary. I feel that the authors are setting the bar too high, and getting angry at failing to achieve “modern” expectations that some people in earlier generations never had.

I accept the consensus that there are too few houses. I accept that jobs are hard to find. I accept that this makes having children harder. But my sympathy is limited where people constrain themselves in ways that I didn’t.

It isn’t that the people in this generation haven’t even started with house-ownership: see “Trends in percentage house ownership of various cohorts“. But we don’t know yet whether this generation will ever achieve the 80% ownership of earlier generations.

Warning about simple age comparisons:
The housing problems of younger people are often expressed in terms of their typical ages. But they should be expressed inter alia in terms of the average time since the end of full time education. In 1965, the average end of full time education was a little over 15, while nowadays it is about 19. This would be expected to increase the average “first-house age” by nearly 4 years over that time. It isn’t valid to be concerned about the higher “first-house ages” of younger people without accounting for such factors.


There have been many incompetent PFI contracts. The book rightly condemns those, but it goes too far in condemning the principle of PFIs just because they pass on costs to people in future.

Consider: Robinson, Marc, 1998, “Measuring Compliance with the Golden Rule,” Fiscal Studies, Vol. 19 (November), pp. 447-62:

“from the golden rule perspective . . . intergenerational equity requires . . . that the costs associated with . . . expenditure should be spread over time in accordance with the distribution over time of the benefits that they generate.”

Now ask “how should this be achieved for the 105 contracts for schools that are currently handled via PFI?” In fact, PFI is already a close approximation to this principle! If a school is run under a PFI contract for 40 years, then the people paying for it over this time are likely to include parents whose children are going to those schools. Under this “golden rule perspective” it would be wrong for the cohort that created the school to have to pay for it all.


Just a couple of points:

  1. When I went to university in 1965 only the top 5% of each year got their tuition free. That is because only the top 5% got to university! (My degree was in Mathematical Physics).
  2. I think apprenticeships will prove more suitable for many people like those who currently go to university then struggle to find jobs. I’m not the only one who thinks that some university courses are a waste of valuable resources for all concerned.

Further reading

This blog

  58 Responses to “Review of “Jilted Generation” by Ed Howker & Shiv Malik”

  1. buy lyrica 75mg generic – lyrica without prescription pregabalin 150mg canada

  2. clomiphene 50mg without prescription – buy cetirizine generic cetirizine 5mg for sale

  3. purchase clarinex without prescription – loratadine tablet order triamcinolone 10mg generic

  4. misoprostol 200mcg cost – cytotec online purchase synthroid pill

  5. sildenafil 100mg usa – gabapentin 800mg ca cost neurontin

  6. tadalafil 5mg price – buy cenforce 100mg pill order cenforce sale

  7. oral diltiazem 180mg – diltiazem ca buy acyclovir

  8. cost atarax 25mg – crestor 10mg sale buy rosuvastatin 10mg pills

  9. sildenafil 150mg price – lisinopril 10mg oral cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg

  10. order sildenafil 150mg generic – purchase cialis without prescription cialis 20mg ca

  11. order generic toradol – cheap ketorolac buy generic baclofen 10mg

  12. gloperba oral – strattera 10mg ca buy strattera 25mg for sale

  13. viagra 150mg cheap – order methotrexate 10mg for sale cheap clopidogrel

  14. order viagra online – order viagra 50mg for sale clopidogrel 75mg brand

  15. buy sildenafil 150mg online cheap – order sildenafil online sildenafil 100mg pills for men

  16. oral esomeprazole 40mg – buy nexium 20mg online buy promethazine 25mg pill

  17. tadalafil 5mg tablet – Real cialis online cialis 5mg tablet

  18. modafinil pills – provigil for sale online ed pills that really work

  19. buy isotretinoin 20mg generic – purchase isotretinoin online buy azithromycin 500mg for sale

  20. purchase lasix online – doxycycline online sildenafil tablets

  21. cialis 20mg canada – generic cialis sildenafil 100mg brand

  22. cialis 20mg for sale – oral warfarin 5mg purchase coumadin without prescription

  23. order avodart sale – tadalafil 5mg tablet order tadalafil 5mg

  24. sildenafil 100mg for sale – sildenafil citrate 50 mg cialis 40mg pills

  25. accutane 20mg usa – amoxil 250mg over the counter cheap amoxil tablets

  26. Wonderful views on that!

  27. order furosemide sale – order azithromycin 500mg sale zithromax generic

  28. doxycycline online order – cheap doxycycline 200mg brand chloroquine

  29. I was excited to discover this website. I wanted to thank you
    for ones time just for this wonderful read!! I definitely savored every bit of it and i also have you book marked to check out new information in your website.

  30. Good article. I’m experiencing some of these issues as

  31. Hi there, I enjoy reading all of your post. I like to
    write a little comment to support you.

  32. Why people still make use of to read news papers when in this technological world the whole thing
    is presented on web?

  33. I like the valuable info you provide in your articles.

    I will bookmark your weblog and check again here frequently.
    I’m quite certain I’ll learn many new stuff right here!

    Good luck for the next!

  34. I’m not sure why but this website is loading very slow for me.

    Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end?
    I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

  35. Hello! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be
    ok. I’m absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

  36. After I originally commented I appear to have clicked the
    -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time
    a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment.
    Perhaps there is a means you can remove me from that service?
    Thank you!

  37. best cialis sites online – Buy cialis next day delivery sildenafil 25mg for sale

  38. order generic modafinil 100mg – viagra cheap sildenafil 150mg drug

  39. top ed drugs – buy prednisone online cheap deltasone 5mg drug

  40. order accutane 20mg online – purchase isotretinoin for sale celebrex online buy

  41. tamsulosin uk – zofran 8mg cheap order spironolactone 25mg for sale

  42. simvastatin 20mg ca – order simvastatin 20mg online cheap research papers writing

  43. slot machine – professional letter writing services help with writing a paper

  44. order ciprofloxacin online – buy cipro 500mg online tadalafil 5mg drug

  45. viagra 150mg for sale – buy deltasone 20mg pill best online vardenafil

  46. Hey there, I think your blog might be having browser
    compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Opera, it looks fine but
    when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, great blog!

  47. Your means of telling the whole thing in this article
    is actually fastidious, all be able to effortlessly be aware
    of it, Thanks a lot.

  48. Hey there! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which
    blog platform are you using for this website? I’m getting sick and
    tired of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for
    another platform. I would be great if you
    could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  49. Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed!
    Extremely useful info particularly the last part :) I care for such
    information a lot. I was looking for this particular info for a very long
    time. Thank you and best of luck.

  50. Ahaa, its nice conversation about this article here at this webpage, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting at
    this place.

  51. prednisolone 40mg pills – cheap tadalafil 10mg cheap tadalafil pill

  52. order augmentin 625mg for sale – augmentin 1000mg oral tadalafil 5mg pills

  53. order bactrim 480mg sale – trimethoprim oral sildenafil 50mg sale

  54. cephalexin 250mg without prescription – order cephalexin 250mg order erythromycin 500mg pills

  55. sildenafil pill – ivermectin 6mg over the counter ivermectin brand name

  56. rhinocort allergy spray – order disulfiram antabuse 500mg canada

 Leave a Reply

Name required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

Email required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>