Aug 172011
 

Holy books talk about such things as: the issues of the day when they were written; the nature of the universe; and how people should think and behave. Each of these separately ceases to be relevant over centuries, even if they ever were relevant.

I’m largely ignoring whether or not gods exist, and whether or not those texts were influenced by gods. Much of what I’m saying applies even if gods exist and influenced those texts!

(I’m basing this article on the Bible and the Koran. What I say may not be true of some other holy books).

“The issues of the day”

Holy texts were typically not written for some distant future audience. They were written for immediate purposes, to gain action from the audience or to re-assure them that relief was coming.

Example from Islam:
Much of what Muhammad “recited” (supposedly from the Angel Gabriel) was concerned with his conflicts (including battles) with other groups, or with his own sex-life. What remained of these statements were later collected together into a single work, (variants were burned), and this (the Koran, or “recital”) is promoted as the final and eternal word of Allah.

The Koran was recited by Muhammad over decades. In the (early) “Mecca years”, he had few followers and little power, so those early parts of the Koran had themes of peace and tolerance. In the (later) “Medina years”, he became a powerful leader and warrior-chief with many followers, and the later parts of the Koran increasingly have themes of battle, intolerance, and what we would see as an unenlightened attitude towards women. There are some incompatibilities, which are typically recognised as needing “abrogation”, with later statements superseding earlier ones.

When Muhammad needed extra wives, whether for personal reasons or to help unite tribes, he received convenient revelations permitting him to do so, and these are in the Koran. These parts of the Koran have no applicability to anyone else at the time or to future generations.

Example from Christianity:
The Bible too often dealt with temporary problems, although typically less personal and much longer lasting than the Koran. (It had many authors, spanning many centuries). Much of the Bible, both old and new testaments, has the context of beleaguered people needing hope for the future.

This continues into the sayings of Jesus, an initially relatively obscure apocalyptic Jewish preacher. His messages were directed at what his disciples should do, and what would happen in the near future.

Holy books would gain relevance and  clarity if they separated historical matters from material intended for future generations.

“The nature of the universe”

The writers of holy books typically couldn’t resist making statements about the nature of the universe that they couldn’t have known. Perhaps this is because (see above) they were not writing for some distant future audience. They were writing for immediate purposes, to gain action from the audience or to re-assure them that relief was coming, and not making the equivalent of scientific predictions. Those statements were often wrong from the start, but it wasn’t until later that this could be judged.

The obvious example is the creation myth in Genesis. (Or rather “myths“, because there are 2 incompatible versions). It is comprehensively contradicted by science (and not just by Evolution).

Here are 3 major obstacles to extending our knowledge and understanding of anything complicated, such as society & morality, or the universe:

  1. There are vastly more ways to be wrong than to be right.
  2. Knowledge and understanding come in dribs and drabs, not all at once.
  3. The inquiry is conducted by fallible human beings.

If we systematically address each of these obstacles, we end up with “the scientific method”. Evidence-based reasoning; open publication; arguments to force more research; models & paradigm shifts; scepticism; peer review; etc.

(Why don’t scientific papers need expiry dates? Because other scientists are eager to make them expire by superseding them! And if authoritative scientists are impeding progress in a particular topic, they can only do so until they die!)

If we fail to address all of these 3 major obstacles, we end up with out-of-date incompatible religions (plural). The “religious method” often resolves conflict by suppression, including force & censorship, or by spawning new religions. Incremental knowledge can meet resistance for centuries.

See: Science versus religion

“How people should think and behave”

Holy texts typically supply a morality; they say how we should behave, and even how we should think. Some of these may have been relevant at the time, perhaps being better than alternatives, but have become out-of-date as we become more sophisticated and mature as a species.

Many religious people claim that their god(s) and holy texts are the source for some sort of absolute or universal morality, and without it we are in danger of an “anything goes” attitude. But there is no universal morality that can be used as a reference:

  • Different religions have different moralities. (As do different groups of non-religious people).
  • The morality of any religion typically evolves over centuries.
  • Different denominations of the same religion tend to have different moralities.
  • Aliens with different biology might necessarily have a different morality. Imagine aliens with one or three sexes.

We all (including atheists) tend to be constrained in our behaviour by: law; human nature; moral zeitgeist; upbringing; local community norms; etc. This builds a morality that each of us starts with. The Moral Zeitgeist is available to all of us. It comprises universal consensuses within a society about what makes something morally acceptable, based originally on our instinctive behaviour. As society changes, so the Moral Zeitgeist itself evolves to adapt to new experiences and conditions. It will typically be compatible with local laws.

Where do modern-day religious people get their moralities? Typically as a mixture of the moralities in their ancient religious texts and the current local Moral Zeitgeist, modified if desired. The more fundamental their religious beliefs, the more the moralities in their religious texts will be used without modification, if necessary by dropping contradictory aspects of the current local Moral Zeitgeist. It is possible for religious people to be enlightened by rejecting the bad bits of their religion, cherry-picking the good bits, and supplementing and complementing those with principles from outside their religion.

See: Ethics and moralities

Discussion

Islam

Muhammad was unenlightened by today’s standards. But many people, Muslims and others, consider that he was progressive for his time, and considerably improved things for many people. Perhaps he would be thought of in a better light had there been expiry dates on the original texts of Islam.

For example, the Koran (and Hadith) defines women as second class people, subject to beatings from their husbands in some cases, with unequal inheritance, and lesser credibility in court. However, many Muslims point out that Muhammad improved the typical status of women compared with their even worse status beforehand. So the following alternatives were possible:

  1. Muhammad’s steps to raise the status of women, (initially from third class status to second class status), can be seen as something for future Muslims to emulate, and by now Muslim women might be first class people, with equal status to men.
  2. Muhammad’s recital of the Koran really was intended to fix women’s second class status for the rest of eternity. And the current validity of the Koran continues that status even in the 21st Century.

Had those bits of the Koran had an expiry date, the first option would have been available for Muslims to further raise the status of women in a progressive way. But the lack of an expiry date fixes Islam at the level of the first steps of what might have been continual improvement, and causes Islam to remain unprogressive; indeed, in comparison with the rest of the world, regressive.

If Muhammad really was (on the whole) a progressive leader by the standards of the day, then without the handicap of its holy texts centuries later, Islam could potentially have been a relatively enlightened religion today, instead of being at best medieval and at worst barbaric.

Christianity

To be fair, some of the things that Jesus said did have an expiry date! He variously said about some of his apocalyptic predictions (Matthew 23:36, Matthew 24:34, and Luke 21:32): “Verily I say unto you, All these things shall come upon this generation”.

But when they didn’t happen, his predictions were (without any justification whatsoever) transferred to a long-distant future, which some people in each century believe means their century (for example, 2011!)

Roman Catholic Church

The Roman Catholic Church appears to have little respect for the Bible. Instead, it relies upon Apostolic Succession. But this doesn’t resolve the problem. Without new input from their God, Apostolic Succession itself needs an expiry date! After all, the pronouncements of the Church’s hierarchy get out of date in the same way that holy books do. We know the Pope doesn’t have a hot-line to Jesus:

“Hi Jesus! We’ve arrested this guy who claims that the Earth revolves around the Sun. We know it’s wrong, but it’s amusing, don’t you think? …. What’s that? It really does revolve around the Sun? Oh Christ … oops … I mean Oh Heck, we’d better let him go and tell everyone the news”.

I don’t believe that religious people would typically honour expiry dates were they provided. But religions are poorer without expiry dates!


“Never trust people who’ve only got one book.” Billy Connolly

  111 Responses to “Holy books need expiry dates”

  1. lyrica drug – buy lyrica for sale lyrica drug

  2. buy clomid 50mg without prescription – zyrtec 10mg usa zyrtec ca

  3. cost clarinex – order clarinex 5mg without prescription purchase triamcinolone without prescription

  4. cytotec 200mcg uk – buy prednisolone 5mg cost synthroid 75mcg

  5. viagra 25 mg – sildenafil for sale buy gabapentin tablets

  6. cialis cost – cialis 5mg canada cenforce online buy

  7. diltiazem 180mg price – buy diltiazem sale acyclovir cheap

  8. generic atarax – purchase rosuvastatin online cheap rosuvastatin order online

  9. buy zetia generic – order generic domperidone 10mg buy generic celexa 20mg

  10. viagra cheap – lisinopril 10mg for sale flexeril price

  11. order sildenafil 150mg online cheap – buy cialis generic cialis buy online

  12. cost toradol 10mg – toradol 10mg sale buy baclofen generic

  13. buy colchicine pills – strattera order strattera for sale online

  14. cheap viagra online – buy methotrexate online order plavix 75mg online cheap

  15. cost sildenafil 150mg – order viagra 50mg pill real viagra 100mg

  16. generic esomeprazole – buy generic nexium purchase phenergan without prescription

  17. tadalafil order online – Cialis online ordering tadalafil 5mg usa

  18. order provigil online – buy provigil sale buy erectile dysfunction drugs

  19. accutane uk – zithromax price azithromycin cost

  20. lasix 40mg pills – doxycycline 200mg price cheap sildenafil generic

  21. generic tadalafil – purchase cialis buy generic sildenafil 100mg

  22. “Thinkin’ ‘bout it.” He answers. “I want to show the world that I am a man, like you. Father.”

    gay anime

  23. order cialis 40mg generic – buy warfarin without prescription buy coumadin 5mg without prescription

  24. “What did Coach have to say when he saw all those hard-young cocks in the locker room?” His dad asks.

    Massive Tits

  25. topiramate 100mg oral – generic topamax 100mg buy sumatriptan 25mg

  26. He does not hear the slamming of the front door. Neither does he hear the footsteps on the wood floor in the hallway. The shower drowns away all this noise.

  27. buy dutasteride pills – price of cialis cialis 20mg canada

  28. “Maybe his dad is right.” He thinks to himself as he continues with his intense fondling of his fiery red cock.

  29. sildenafil 100mg cheap – cheap cialis without prescription order cialis 5mg

  30. In this awesome pattern of things you receive a B+ for effort. Exactly where you actually confused me personally was on the particulars. You know, it is said, details make or break the argument.. And it could not be more correct right here. Having said that, allow me say to you what exactly did do the job. Your text can be highly powerful and this is probably why I am taking the effort to opine. I do not make it a regular habit of doing that. Secondly, despite the fact that I can certainly see the leaps in reason you come up with, I am not necessarily convinced of how you seem to connect your details which in turn make your conclusion. For now I will subscribe to your issue however trust in the future you actually link your facts better. forums.prosportsdaily.com

  31. buy erectile dysfunction medicine – prednisone 20mg us order prednisone 20mg online

  32. isotretinoin 20mg canada – generic amoxicillin 1000mg amoxil online order

  33. furosemide 40mg ca – order zithromax 250mg generic cheap azithromycin 500mg

  34. I didn’t know that.

  35. Why is it I always really feel like you do?

  36. cheap doxycycline 100mg – buy chloroquine generic chloroquine buy online

  37. buy cialis 40mg generic – Discount canadian cialis order viagra 150mg for sale

  38. Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasant thought, post is
    good, thats why i have read it fully

  39. What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered It absolutely helpful and it
    has helped me out loads. I’m hoping to contribute &
    assist other customers like its aided me. Great job.

  40. constantly i used to read smaller articles that as
    well clear their motive, and that is also happening with this post which I
    am reading here.

  41. Highly descriptive blog, I liked that bit. Will
    there be a part 2?

  42. I read this paragraph completely on the topic of the difference of most up-to-date and earlier
    technologies, it’s amazing article.

  43. modafinil 100mg cheap – buy provigil 200mg pills sildenafil cost

  44. best non prescription ed pills – order prednisone 10mg pills generic prednisone 5mg

  45. isotretinoin oral – brand accutane 10mg order celebrex 100mg for sale

  46. flomax without prescription – buy aldactone 25mg generic order spironolactone 25mg

  47. simvastatin 20mg ca – buy zocor 10mg online assignment sites

  48. casino online slots – help with writing a paper write thesis

  49. online casino games – gambling website acillin uk

  50. order cipro online cheap – buy cialis 20mg pills order cialis 10mg online

  51. sildenafil 150mg – generic viagra cialis vardenafil cheap vardenafil for women

  52. Yes! Finally something about health supplement.

  53. Hello it’s me, I am also visiting this site on a regular basis, this web page is
    truly nice and the users are genuinely sharing fastidious
    thoughts.

  54. Hi my loved one! I want to say that this post is awesome,
    nice written and come with almost all important infos.

    I’d like to peer more posts like this .

  55. buy augmentin 625mg without prescription – purchase augmentin generic buy tadalafil online

  56. sulfamethoxazole for sale – cost of viagra 100mg generic sildenafil 50mg

  57. order cephalexin generic – purchase cephalexin generic buy erythromycin

  58. Have you ever considered about including a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything. But just imagine if you added some great pictures or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and clips, this website could certainly be one of the best in its field. Very good blog!|

  59. order fildena pill – stromectol buy canada oral stromectol cost

  60. budesonide over the counter – order cialis 5mg online purchase antabuse online

  61. cefuroxime 250mg us – order tadalafil for sale buy cialis 20mg

  62. ampicillin us – acillin sale order tadalafil 40mg generic

  63. amoxicillin 500mg without prescription – amoxicillin cheap order generic vardenafil 10mg

  64. ivermectin 12 mg over the counter – buy ivermectin 3mg order vardenafil online

  65. buy doxycycline 100mg online – buy doxycycline 200mg us cialis

  66. cialis 40mg brand – canada online pharmacies order modafinil 200mg pills

  67. deltasone us – accutane ca oral accutane 10mg

  68. Spot on with this write-up, I actually think this website needs much more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the information!|

  69. order amoxicillin for sale – buy viagra 150mg pills buy sildenafil 100mg sale

  70. It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d certainly donate to this brilliant blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this website with my Facebook group. Talk soon!|

  71. It’s an amazing article in favor of all the online users; they will obtain benefit from it I am sure.|

  72. cheap prednisolone – sildenafil citrate 50mg real viagra

  73. buy furosemide 40mg without prescription – doxycycline 200mg drug ivermectin 3mg dose

  74. Aw, this was a really nice post. Spending some
    time and actual effort to generate a really good article… but what can I say…
    I procrastinate a whole lot and don’t manage to
    get nearly anything done.

  75. hydroxychloroquine 400mg brand – chloroquine 250mg brand purchase baricitinib for sale

  76. generic metformin 1000mg – order generic lipitor order norvasc without prescription

  77. levitra drug – methylprednisolone order online clomiphene order online

  78. albuterol over the counter – real money online casino dapoxetine 30mg sale

  79. Психолог онлайн. Консультация Прием психолога? – 7587 врачей, 5115 отзывов.

  80. synthroid over the counter – purchase aristocort for sale plaquenil brand

  81. Психолог онлайн. Консультация Психолога
    - 3485 врачей, 6857 отзывов.

  82. buying azithromycin online zithromax online purchase what is azithromycin 500mg used for how long does azithromycin stay in the body

  83. diltiazem hydrochloride sell cartia xt 120 mg generic diltiazem extended-release dose what is the difference between diltiazem er 180mg caps (xr-24h) and dilt-xr 180mg capsules

  84. Психолог онлайн. Консультация Прием психолога? – 7688 врачей, 4606 отзывов.

  85. Психолог онлайн. Консультация Психолога
    – 7081 врачей, 6927 отзывов.

  86. Психолог онлайн. Консультация Когда необходим прием психолога?
    – 4185 врачей, 7639 отзывов.

  87. tadalafil 10mg price – pfizer viagra sildenafil dosage

  88. order deltasone 10mg without prescription – buy generic accutane online cheap oral amoxil 1000mg

  89. buy generic diltiazem – buy gabapentin 600mg pill buy neurontin generic

  90. azithromycin in spanish azithromycin pills can you take nyquil with azithromycin how do you take azithromycin

  91. Смотреть онлайн фильм. Смотреть онлайн.
    Фильм. Хотя в летний кинотеатр.
    Фильмы и сериалы – смотреть эфир онлайн.

  92. purchase furosemide pill – buy zyloprim online cheap brand doxycycline 100mg

  93. Фильм · Рейтинг · Год: · Страна: · Жанр:
    · Время:.. Доступ качестве основного.
    Смотреть онлайн бесплатно в
    хорошем качестве.

  94. cenforce 100mg us – order zetia online cheap buy motilium 10mg pill

  95. Смотреть порно бесплатно категории онлайн шд:
    . Открыто качестве члена.

    Смотреть онлайн фильмы и сериалы

  96. zithromax pneumonia azithromycin generic cost india does azithromycin cause yeast infections how much is azithromycin

  97. viagra and levitra taken together levitra reviews vs viagra levitra malaysia levitra dosage medication doctor

  98. viagra 150mg for sale – cialis us purchase tadalafil for sale

  99. modafinil 100mg cheap – order rhinocort generic order budesonide pills

  100. viagra sildenafil viagra on steroids where can l buy viagra how to get viagra in sydney

  101. canada viagra online cialis 5mg online australia where can i buy generic viagra how is viagra used

  102. buy accutane 40mg online – buy zithromax 250mg online cheap order tetracycline 500mg pills

  103. Смотрите ваши любимые шоу, сериалы и фильмы онлайн!.
    Открыто тор любовь и гром разбор тизера.
    Фильмы и сериалы – смотреть эфир онлайн.

  104. clomid experience where can i buy clomid online in australia when does clomid make you ovulate where can i buy clomid in canada

  105. latisse cheapest side effects of lumigan eye drops does latisse and tetrahydrozoline effect your eyes how to apply latisse to eyelashes

  106. Илоило (2013). Ilo Ilo. Буду смотреть..
    Здесь Тор 4 Любовь и гром.
    Смотрите онлайн фильмы, в хорошем качестве, много бесплатных видео.

 Leave a Reply

Name required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

Email required. (Spam NEVER gets published before being trashed)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>