Aug 302011
 

This is the 3rd of a 3-part discussion on alcohol drinking guidelines:
Part 1: Alcohol consumption at the Royal College of Psychiatrists
Part 2: Alcohol consumption – science and politics
Part 3: This article

Preamble

I started this 3-part discussion because of the recommendations in the report “Our invisible addicts” by the Royal College of Psychiatrists about alcohol guidelines in the over-64s. They were wrong on a number of levels. Much of the literature on alcohol consumption suffers from one of the errors made by that report: there is a failure to see the issue from the individual drinker’s perspective. As I said in Part 2 (see also “The origins of the UK’s alcohol guidelines” in Part 1):

“Drinking guidelines are relatively arbitrary decisions made by committees for social engineering purposes. They do not relate to any specific drinker”.

“The various participants have their own separate agendas…. So drinkers, front-line health professionals, and politicians, can be expected to pull in different directions.”

Also in Part 2, I posed the following questions, concerned with individual drinkers’ ability to make their own informed decisions. I want to inject part of the drinker’s perspective into the discussion, so that such questions appear reasonable.

“If my alcohol drinking pattern and quantity is X, what is my increased mortality rate?”

“How much alcohol can I drink for an increased mortality rate of X?”

Terminology and the tyranny of the discontinuous mind

Richard Dawkins introduced the term “the tyranny of the discontinuous mind” in his super book “The Ancestor’s Tale”. It identifies problems with putting things into rigid categories when they would be better treated as continua. I think analytically; it was a necessary trait in a career spent (inter alia) helping to design complicated computer systems. I therefore run the risk of being such a tyrant myself, so I have to be sensitive to inappropriate categorisation. And drinking guidelines fall into this trap!

Typical terminology mapped onto the “J Curve”

This is a typical dose-response J Curve, with the relative risk initially falling from the abstention level, then rising again, as alcohol consumption increases. I haven’t put more values on the vertical axis because there is no consensus, and it doesn’t matter for this discussion.

This particular terminology came from the following, but it is typical of many other documents too:

Alcohol-use disorders: preventing the development of hazardous and harmful drinking (NHS / NICE)
Alcohol misuse: tackling the UK epidemic (BMA Board of Science)

Guidelines

The green lines correspond to the UK’s drinking guidelines, at 21 units per week for men. So the consumption of 21 units per week leads to a relative risk of “G” (whatever that is). The guideline for women is lower, but the dose-response curve is different for women too. This doesn’t matter for this discussion.

The values were largely “plucked out of the air” decades ago; see: “The origins of the UK’s alcohol guidelines” in Part 1. A committee with different members on it would probably have chosen different numbers. (Why are the numbers for both men and women, 21 and 14 respectively, multiples of 7?) Other countries use different numbers, and have different sizes of unit. The UK numbers have since been tweaked by adding values for daily consumption, and extra numbers have been “plucked out of the air” to identify the “higher risk” category, but the weekly values have not changed. Even though the science is now much better than when the values were originally chosen, the above diagram shows why no scientific research can directly derive the guidelines.

Where should the lines be drawn? Why not choose drinking levels that give the same relative risk as “0″ alcohol consumption (abstention)? Or why not choose the consumption at the “nadir”, the point of lowest mortality rate (“B”, the blue line)? Those are the only values which are not relatively arbitrary. Typical research indicates that the guidelines are set at a level which gives a higher relative risk than both abstention and the nadir. They result in a higher mortality rate than alternatives.

What is the relative risk for the population, (or subsets of the population), corresponding to the guidelines? In other words, what is the value “G”, where the green line meets the vertical axis? Does anyone actually know? The government and health professionals are recommending alcohol levels that result in this particular risk: shouldn’t we at least know what risk of death they are recommending us to accept, and why?

Population values versus individual drinker values

Even if the guidelines were derived in a credible way from researched dose-response curves for the whole population, they would still not be “accurate” for individuals. People differ from one-another in their medical tolerance of alcohol, and any person’s tolerance changes at different ages.  I said in Part 2 (similar to this abstract):

“It would be unethical to advise any person to adhere to them [the guidelines] without investigating the physical and environmental conditions of that person first. It would be equivalent to advising medical intervention for someone without knowing about them.”

If these were promoted as population-based guidelines, that would at least be honest. But they are promoted as though they really do apply to individual drinkers. And this becomes worse when terminology is chosen to add “spin” to the values.

Choice of terminology

Since the values were “plucked out of the air” decades ago, they have taken on a life of their own. Terminology has grown up around them. You may stray from “sensible drinking” to “hazardous drinking” with just a few extra units a week, even though there is hardly any actual change in relative risk.

Given the different tolerances of different people, one person may be safer with “hazardous drinking” than another with “sensible drinking”. Consumption that was “sensible drinking” at one age may be “hazardous drinking” at another; or vice versa. (See Part 2). Or move to a different country and you can drink the same amount with a different (more or less worrying) term associated with that amount!

“Misuse of alcohol”

A particularly unreasonable term is “misuse of alcohol”, (or “alcohol misuse”, etc), to mean (inter alia) “drinking beyond the guidelines”. This is a judgemental term, for example “Alcohol misuse: The use of alcohol for a purpose not consistent with legal or medical guidelines“, (see: Alcohol misuse: tackling the UK epidemic, but there is similar use elsewhere). Presumably, given that the guidelines are for social engineering purposes, it is necessary to cause people to act en masse whether they individually need to or not.

This is also sloppy logic. “Misuse” of something can credibly only be defined in relation to “proper use”. So what is “proper use of alcohol”? Let’s discuss that!

Proper use of alcohol

I’m ambitious; I intend to derive a plausible definition of “proper use of alcohol”! But first it is necessary to examine alcohol from 3 perspectives:

Perspective 1: Alcohol is a poison (or a sin)

This is sometimes a religious view. But it can also be a “puritan” view, without necessarily a religious influence. See: Alcohol as evil – Temperance and policy (Stanton Peele, 2010)

Without qualification, this view has no merit. I won’t waste time refuting it here, other than to point to the other 2 perspectives below which are incompatible with this view. However, this view appears to be the implicit basis of lots of documents on alcohol policy. They often start with a sentence something like “Many people enjoy drinking alcohol, but ….” then continue for dozens of pages as though the policy should be to eliminate alcohol from society because it has nothing going for it!

Perspective 2: Alcohol is a preventive medicine with significant bad side-effects

This is a major theme of Part 2, for some but not all illnesses. It especially appears to be a valid view for older people. It is validated if the “J Curve” above is the real dose-response curve for the population as a whole. Very many science papers says this is true, but a few are skeptical, or at least say that the bad side-effects out-weigh the prevention.

I think there is too much science at the biochemical level showing how this prevention works for this view to be dismissed.

Perspective 3: Alcohol is a quality-of-life enhancer with various significant side-effects

This view sometimes appears to be overlooked by governments and front-line health professionals! But it has been known by lots of people in lots of countries over lots of centuries. Since I know it is true for me, and by empathy I realise that others are probably telling the truth when they say it is true for them, I accept this view. (Who can judge “quality of life”? The person living that life is the final arbiter!)

Purposeful use of alcohol

Perspective 1 can safely be dismissed. Perspectives 2 and 3 are reasonably compatible with one-another, and can be combined into a comprehensive view of drinking.

Alcohol is a preventive medicine and quality-of-life enhancer with significant bad side-effects

Purposeful use of alcohol is to help prevent (or delay, or reduce) various illnesses that the drinker needs to be concerned about, and/or to enhance the quality of life measured over a substantial period of time (not just for the duration of the immediate effect).

Proper use of alcohol

Purposeful use may still have unnecessary bad side-effects. Proper use eliminates unnecessary bad side-effects, for example by avoiding the acute risks arising from intoxication, and avoids conflict with the law, without significantly reducing the benefits of prevention and quality-of-life enhancement. So:

Proper use of alcohol is use of alcohol to help prevent (or delay, or reduce) various illnesses that the drinker needs to be concerned about, and/or to enhance the quality of life measured over a substantial period of time (not just for the duration of the immediate effect), while eliminating unnecessary bad side-effects and any conflict with the law.

Misuse of alcohol is use of alcohol that is incompatible with proper use of alcohol.

Why “Our invisible addicts” is wrong about alcohol consumption

The alcohol-guidelines part of the report “Our invisible addicts” by the Royal College of Psychiatrists is like a fart in a lift – it is wrong on many levels:

  • It attributes to one of its references a position not held. It cannot validly make the recommendation it does without either identifying a document that supports its case, or providing its own evidence for its recommendations.
  • It lumps together the “65s and over”, as though they are a category of people who are infirm and/or taking medicines that are incompatible with alcohol. (What is going to happen to me next year when I hit this dreadful age? Will I suddenly have to take lots of medicine? Will I suddenly become infirm? Why hasn’t this happened to all the over 65s I know? Do only 65s and over have these problems?)
  • It ignores the preventive effects of alcohol on the illnesses of old-age.
  • It ignores the importance of alcohol as a quality-of-life enhancer. Think of a group of people, about 70 years old, who go to the pub for a natter most days. They perhaps spend a few hours drinking a few pints and G&Ts. Would life be better for them if they limited themselves to less than a pint or no more than single G&T? That sounds like a recipe for losing the will to live!

Risk of death and quality of life

Much of the attitude towards alcohol consumption is about the risk of death posed by alcohol. This risk of death is seen by many people as something to be avoided, even at considerable cost. Yet see: Assisted suicide – time for change. I want the law changed so that I have the option of taking a drug that carries a 100% risk of killing me in minutes. I want this option as an alternative to living with an unacceptable (to me) quality of life. Any analysis of the risk of alcohol consumption that doesn’t consider the effect of alcohol on the quality of life is potentially worthless. Living longer isn’t the most important objective of life.

Given that I am prepared to make a trade-off between quality of life and length of life, (and so are lots of other people), we should have available the information we need for this. See the questions posed in the Preamble at the top of this article.

I suspect some of the information needed is out there. See: ‘Optimal’ levels of alcohol consumption for men and women at different ages, and the all-cause mortality attributable to drinking (Ian R. White, Dan R. Altmann and Kiran Nanchahal) (2006):

“We investigated the levels of alcohol consumption at which risk is 5% more than risk at the nadir. This may correspond to an acceptable increase in risk for an individual, although a 5% increase in risk for everyone in England and Wales would imply 27000 extra deaths each year….

“For women the 5% bound is 8 units/week at ages 16-24 and increases to around 20 units/week at ages over 85. For men the 5% bound is only 5 units/week at ages 16-24 (reflecting the steeper slope of the risk curve in young men than in young women) and increases to 30-35 units/week at ages over 65.” [My emphasis]

So, when I am over 65, my current drinking level, (about half a bottle of wine about 6 days a week, or just over 30 units per week), will correspond to this 5% extra risk compared with the nadir. (This is significantly less than 5% extra compared with the guidelines, which may themselves have about 2% or 3% extra risk compared with the nadir).

Other reading

‘Safe’ drinking guidelines to be reviewed
Safe drinking limits to be reviewed
Is the writing on the wall for alcohol units?
Are the recommended guidelines ‘nannying’?

  4,828 Responses to “Alcohol consumption – discussion”

  1. I came across your excellent series of articles while searching, in vain, for the scientific basis for alcohol consumption guidelines. I am an unreformed crumblie who enjoys a couple of glasses of the fermented grape every night with dinner and I am still tottering cheerfully towards my dotage with no signs of ill health so far. I completely agree that quality of life should be our primary goal and I find it tiresome that we are constantly nagged about our ‘lifestyles’. Wine makes me feel happy, relaxed and at one with the world. I’m originally from the UK but have lived in Canada since 1976, and we are also bombarded by messages about ‘moderate’ alcohol consumption, which seems to translate into a thimble-ful per day. It’s too late for me to die young, so I’m going to continue with my reckless behaviour and try and ignore the nattering nabobs of negativity currently masquerading as our glorious leaders.

  2. lyrica 75mg sale – generic pregabalin brand pregabalin

  3. clomiphene canada – order clomid 50mg generic zyrtec for sale online

  4. desloratadine us – generic aristocort 4mg purchase aristocort sale

  5. misoprostol canada – order prednisolone 40mg levothyroxine generic

  6. sildenafil canada – viagra 100 mg buy gabapentin 600mg generic

  7. cidofovir, brand name vistide, is an injectable antiviral medication primarily used as a treatment for cytomegalovirus (cmv) retinitis (an infection of the retina of the eye) in people with aids.

    cidofovir was approved for medical use in 1996.

    medical use
    dna virus
    its only indication that has received regulatory approval worldwide is cytomegalovirus retinitis. cidofovir has also shown efficacy in the treatment of aciclovir-resistant hsv infections. cidofovir has also been investigated as a treatment for progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy with successful case reports of its use. despite this, the drug failed to demonstrate any efficacy in controlled studies. cidofovir might have anti-smallpox efficacy and might be used on a limited basis in the event of a bioterror incident involving smallpox cases. brincidofovir, a cidofovir derivative with much higher activity against smallpox that can be taken orally has been developed. it has inhibitory effects on varicella-zoster virus replication in vitro although no clinical trials have been done to date, likely due to the abundance of safer alternatives such as aciclovir. cidofovir shows anti-bk virus activity in a subgroup of transplant recipients. cidofovir is being investigated as a complementary intralesional therapy against papillomatosis caused by hpv.

    it first received fda approval on 26 june 1996, tga approval on 30 april 1998 and ema approval on 23 april 1997.

    it has been used topically to treat warts.

  8. tadalafil 20mg oral – cheap tadalafil generic cenforce 100mg oral

  9. diltiazem over the counter – allopurinol over the counter buy acyclovir online

  10. order atarax – hydroxyzine online buy order rosuvastatin 10mg without prescription

  11. buy zetia 10mg generic – celexa 20mg drug celexa pills

  12. pfizer viagra 50mg – order cyclobenzaprine online cheap order flexeril

  13. Девять знатных семей сражаются за контроль над королевствами Вестероса, тем временем старинный враг приходит после векового бездействия.
    игра престолов lostfilm смотреть

  14. purchase viagra generic – buy cialis 20mg pills order tadalafil 10mg pill

  15. order toradol pills – tizanidine order online order baclofen 10mg pills

  16. colchicine drug – order strattera 25mg purchase strattera pill

  17. viagra 100mg us – buy plavix 75mg online cheap buy plavix 75mg pills

  18. INFORMATION
    What you need to know about USCS Wedge Type Clamp
    It’s easy not to be stressed out with cable management. Strong winds, frost, and UV rays are not exactly a communication or electrical cable’s best of friends to make them last for a long time. A lot of times, news of hurricanes and other weather disturbances sends a chilling warning to cable people and gives them a lot of reason to worry.
    tension clamp

  19. nexium online order – promethazine price promethazine 25mg for sale

  20. cialis 20mg cheap – Canadian generic cialis cheap cialis 40mg

  21. cost provigil – online ed pills best drug for ed

  22. order isotretinoin 10mg online – amoxicillin 250mg pill buy azithromycin 500mg pill

  23. order furosemide 100mg generic – doxycycline 200mg cheap viagra pharmacy

  24. cheap tadalafil for sale – sildenafil 100mg uk viagra us

  25. Fast game – прекрасный метод моментально познать фортуну. Во раунде данного порядка принимет участие в целом 3 игрока со лимитированием наибольшей ставки. Чемпион приобретет вклад троих инвесторов.
    Double game – порядок вид развлечения, во коем Вам сможете получить монеты (денежная еденица обслуживания) также поменять их в скины с Торгового Центра. Отгадайте триумфальный тон также возвращайте собственную ставку во 2х либо 14ти сложном объеме.
    ксгофаст

  26. “You have not fucked, have you, my son? Have you?” His father asks, as he readjusts the cock covered and swelling in his khaki pants. “I thought as much.”

    big dildo

  27. order cialis 10mg – buy cozaar 25mg online buy warfarin 5mg generic

  28. “Yep. I’ve had one since I put on my gear at practice today.” He tells his dad.

  29. avodart online – brand tadalafil 20mg order cialis 10mg pill

  30. televend market https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet market status

  31. buy viagra tablets – generic cialis 5mg cheap tadalafil tablets

  32. black market prices for drugs dark web sites

  33. generic isotretinoin – amoxicillin drug order amoxicillin 1000mg for sale

  34. I didn’t know that.

  35. purchase lasix – zithromax 500mg cost azithromycin over the counter

  36. Why is it I always really feel like you do?

  37. doxycycline tablet – doxycycline for sale online buy aralen online

  38. Hi, I log on to your blog on a regular basis. Your humoristic style is awesome, keep up the good work!

  39. dark web drug marketplace deep web markets

  40. This website truly has all of the info I wanted about this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

  41. Highly energetic blog, I loved that a lot.
    Will there be a part 2?

  42. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this superb blog!
    I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your
    RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this website with my Facebook group.
    Chat soon!

  43. I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this sort
    of area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this site.
    Studying this information So i’m happy to show that I have an incredibly
    good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I
    needed. I most indisputably will make sure to don?t fail to remember this web site and
    give it a look on a relentless basis.

  44. Great work! This is the type of info that should be shared across
    the web. Shame on the seek engines for now not positioning this publish higher!
    Come on over and seek advice from my site . Thanks =)

  45. I always emailed this weblog post page to all my friends, since if like to read it then my contacts
    will too.

  46. I must thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this site.
    I really hope to see the same high-grade blog posts from you later
    on as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own website
    now ;)

  47. It’s remarkable to visit this web site and reading the
    views of all colleagues concerning this post, while I am also
    keen of getting knowledge.

  48. Heya are using WordPress for your blog platform?
    I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my
    own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog?
    Any help would be really appreciated!

  49. Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am encountering issues with your RSS.
    I don’t know why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody getting
    similar RSS issues? Anyone who knows the answer will you kindly respond?

    Thanks!!

  50. We are a gaggle of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.
    Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on. You’ve done
    an impressive task and our entire group will be thankful to you.

  51. Excellent blog right here! Also your website lots up very fast!
    What host are you the use of? Can I am getting your affiliate link on your host?
    I want my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  52. tadalafil for sale online – Cialis without prescription viagra 50mg pill

  53. order modafinil – modafinil 200mg cheap viagra pill

  54. Компания avtonomera24.su уже более 5 лет занимается изготовлением автономеров всех типов. Мы работаем только на сертифицированном немецком оборудовании. Изготовим номера за 2 минуты, а экспресс-доставка по всему миру позволяет оперативно передавать заказы нашим клиентам. Предлагаем воспользоваться услугой по изготовлению любых типов гос. номеров на все виды транспорта. Иногда возникает потребность в изготовлении новых номеров в следствии утери или дтп, в таких случаях необходимо обращаться к нам, что бы приобрести госзнаки быстро и без очередей, ведь езда без гос. номеров является сильным нарушением закона и очень строго карается представителями ГАИ в виде штрафа от 3000-5000 рублей, либо лешением прав на срок до 6 месяцев. Сотрудничество с нашей компанией – это гарантия безпроблемного передвижения по дорогам без проблем с ГИБДД. Успейте оформить заказ прямо сейчас и мы подарим вам дополнительную скидку.

    номерной знак дубликат

  55. best ed pills at gnc – canadian drug pharmacy buy generic deltasone 10mg

  56. order isotretinoin generic – order accutane 10mg order celecoxib 200mg for sale

  57. purchase tamsulosin – purchase aldactone generic purchase aldactone online

  58. dark web drug marketplace darkmarket link

  59. zocor for sale online – essays help paper writing online

  60. casino slot games – pay for essay writing uk paperwriter

  61. casino online usa – cheap propecia 5mg generic ampicillin 500mg

  62. dark web drug marketplace dark web markets

  63. cipro online buy – order ciprofloxacin pill purchase cialis pill

  64. Do you like to win? You deserve more!
    Visit us http://lumisity.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=fastpay-casino.biz
    A lot of interesting things

  65. order sildenafil pill – viagra in usa buy vardenafil 10mg online

  66. You ought to be a part of a contest for one of the greatest blogs on the internet.
    I’m going to highly recommend this web site!

  67. Hi there! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone!
    Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your
    posts! Carry on the fantastic work!

  68. Do you want to be the first? Don’t sit around!
    Look here http://www.caids.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=vendetuarma.com%2Fauthor%2Flloydhixson%2F
    Interesting stories

  69. Good site you have got here.. It’s difficult to find high quality writing like yours
    nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you!

    Take care!!

  70. buy augmentin 625mg sale – order cialis 40mg online cheap order cialis 40mg without prescription

  71. purchase bactrim without prescription – brand viagra pills order sildenafil

  72. Букмекерська компанія PariMatch продовжує відкрито працювати в Білорусі та Росії. Про це повідомляє UA Report.
    Автори матеріалу показали відео зі столиці Білорусі, де банери букмекера майорять на найдорожчих майданчиках Мінська. Також PariMatch спонсорує спортивні клуби у Республіці Білорусь, з території якої запускають ракети, повідомляють в матеріалі.
    «Є така компанія PariMatch, яка де-факто працює в Білорусі та воює проти нас. Працює досі в Україні», — каже у коментарі політолог Тарас Загородній. Ведуча телемарафону коментуючи слова фахівця додала: «Саме ця компанія про яку ви говорите — недавно отримала ліцензію під час війни…»
    У Росії, як повідомляє UA Report, компанія фіктивно відкликала франшизу.
    Хоча насправді тільки змінила назву та продовжує заробляти там кошти, сплачувати податки з яких потім армія окупантів створює ракети для вбивств українців.
    Факти про продовження роботи в Росії журналісти наводять у матеріалі. Зокрема — зміна назви баскетбольного клубу посеред сезону з Парма-ПаріМатч у Парма-ПаріБет.

  73. Do you like to bet? You can do more!
    Find what you need here https://casinooftheplains.com/contact-us/

    Cool features

  74. Некоторые борцы за справедливость на поверку оказались абсолютно меркантильными персонажами. Вместо того, чтобы бросить все свои силы на то, чтобы помочь нашей армии, они занимаются откровенно грязными схемами.
    На днях известный киевский активист и политик Александр Рак разродился весьма неожиданным заявлением: дескать, в Киеве нужно «развивать электротранспорт и велоинфраструктуру». Повод для подобных заявлений – острый дефицит бензина на заправках города. По логике господина Рака выходит,что теперь вся столица должна пересесть на велосипеды и электроскутеры, и это решило бы все проблемы. Абсурд полнейший: сейчас – во время страшной бойни с россией, с полууничтоженной экономикой – «самое время» говорить о велодорожках…
    Впрочем, нужно понимать мотивацию Рака, который давно «присел» на темы «распила» бюджетов именно по темам строительства велодорожек. Тут стоит вспомнить, что в 2020 году он баллотировался в Киевсовет по Соломенскому району от партии «Голос», но зайти в горсовет ему не удалось. Однако парень не растерялся: сталпомощником—консультантом депутата Киевсовета от «Голос» Григория Маленко.

  75. Do you like to win? Don’t sit around!
    Find what you need here https://casinos-and-more.info/2010/10/

    Cool features

  76. Do you like to bet? You deserve more!
    Look here https://goldencrowncasinologin.com/

    A lot of useful information

  77. Hot new pictures each day
    http://freecopsporn.gigixo.com/?raquel

    orgasm porns free naked sex porn banned boys porn free natural breast porn videos story category porn video

  78. Do you like to bet? You deserve more!
    Useful material here A lot of useful information

  79. order cephalexin 125mg online – cephalexin oral erythromycin 250mg cheap

  80. guide to darknet markets darknet market list – darknet market url list

  81. В Киеве возобновились работы на строительстве элитного ЖК Stanford, к которому может быть причастен нардеп ликвидированной ОПЗЖ Дмитрий Исаенко. Высотки возводятся на территории предприятия оборонно-промышленного комплекса «Радар», пишет Марина Супрун для СтопКор.
    Земельный участок расположен на элитном Печерске и находится в постоянном использовании завода. В 2016 году с «Радаром» был заключен договор о долевом участии в капитальном строительстве ЖК. Когда начинались работы, целевым предназначением на земле было размещение и эксплуатация основных, подсобных и вспомогательных зданий. Из-за нарушений со стороны девелопера было открыто уголовное производство. Впрочем, уже в апреле 2021 года застройщик через суд закрыл вопрос с целевым назначением. Так же суд признал застройщика правым в тяжбах с ГАСИ, да и почти во всех других делах. Да, на земельные участки неоднократно налагали арест, но решением суда его отменяли. О чем раньше рассказывала журналистка проекту «Стоп коррупции» Мария Гураль.

  82. buy fildena 100mg without prescription – purchase oral stromectol ivermectin 4 mg

  83. Hello. And Bye.

  84. grams darknet market search engine cannazon market link – zion market darknet

  85. Do you like to bet? Don’t stop!
    Useful material here https://cobber-casino.net/ru/

    Cool features

  86. budesonide allergy spray – cialis oral order disulfiram 500mg pill

  87. mexican pharmacies online
    trusted online pharmacy reviews

  88. Hot new pictures each day
    http://free-asian-lesbian.porn-movies.miaxxx.com/?post-darby
    porn videos ameature free full length man dog porn pics hot sexy free male porn porn movie major slut downloadable free lesbian porn

  89. empire darknet market dark0de market – link darknet market

  90. ФСБ задержала бывшего украинского морпеха, готовившего теракт в ТРЦ в Симферополе
    ФСБ РФ задержала бывшего украинского морпеха, готовившего по указанию националистов полка “Азов” теракт в ТРЦ в Симферополе.N]

    omgomg

  91. Свердловский губернатор Куйвашев посоветовал телеведущему Соловьеву следить за языком
    Губернатор Свердловской области Евгений Куйвашев ответил телеведущему Владимиру Соловьеву, который во время интервью с уральским полпредом Владимиром Якушевым назвал Екатеринбург «центром мерзотной либероты».
    Lenta.ru
    «На Урале очень любят и ценят людей, которые следят за своим языком, поэтому желаю вам следить за своим языком», — заявил Куйвашев, комментируя заявление Соловьева.
    Lenta.ru
    На днях в прямом эфире телеведущий Владимир Соловьев сделал резкое заявление про Екатеринбург.
    Моменты
    «В Екатеринбурге есть свои бесы», – заявил Соловьев на телеканале «Россия-1» и обвинил сенатора Эдуарда Росселя в отсутствии

    omgomg

  92. my canadian pharmacy
    pharmacy technician online

  93. cefuroxime generic – purchase tadalafil generic order tadalafil online

  94. В игре две команды; В каждой команде по пять персонажей. Вы можете выбрать одного и играть только за него все раунды данной игры. Не важно кого вы выберете: мясника, доктора или саппорта — вы должны выложиться по полной.
    Новые виды борьбы
    В битве вы исполюзуете такие виды техники и оружия, о которых вы раньше даже не мечтали. Вас удивит геймплей и графика игры.
    Мнение эксперта:
    Данил Александрович Ишутин. также известный как «Dendi».  Победитель International Dota.
    Достоинства:
    Новый жанр в игровой индустрии, графика, динамика.
    Недостатки:
    Все пожалуй слышали о нашумевшем проекте Overwatch. А ведь и правда, мы знаем Blizzard по таким шедеврам как World of Warcraft, StarCraft, Diablo, так же не давно появилась Heroes of the storm хотя для меня это больше, такой вызов Blizzard таким гигантам как LoL и Dota 2. И тут нам сообщают что метелица внедрила чуть ли не новый жанр MOBA от первого лица! Удивлены? Я тоже.

  95. deep web drug markets darkmarket

  96. ampicillin 500mg brand – ampicillin ca tadalafil 10mg cheap

  97. buy amoxil online cheap – brand vardenafil 20mg buy vardenafil 20mg without prescription

  98. I absolutely love your blog and find the majority of your post’s
    to be precisely what I’m looking for. can you offer guest writers to write content for yourself?
    I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects
    you write regarding here. Again, awesome weblog!

  99. Hi there, I discovered your website via Google while searching for a similar
    subject, your site got here up, it appears to be
    like great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    Hi there, simply was alert to your blog via Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you continue this in future.
    Numerous folks will likely be benefited from your writing.
    Cheers!

  100. Good article. I’m facing many of these issues as well..

  101. Truly no matter if someone doesn’t know then its
    up to other people that they will assist, so here it occurs.

  102. dark web market links dark market

  103. ivermectin cream cost – stromectol stromectol buy vardenafil 20mg cheap

  104. I think that everything said made a bunch of sense.

    But, what about this? what if you wrote a catchier post title?
    I am not saying your information isn’t solid, however what if you
    added a post title to possibly get a person’s attention?
    I mean Alcohol consumption – discussion » Barry's blog is a little boring.

    You might look at Yahoo’s home page and see how they write article titles to get people interested.
    You might add a video or a related pic or two to grab people excited about everything’ve written. In my opinion, it would make your posts a little livelier.

  105. I’m no longer sure where you’re getting your information, but good topic.

    I must spend some time finding out more or figuring out more.

    Thanks for wonderful info I used to be in search of
    this information for my mission.

  106. Good post. I am experiencing some of these issues as well..

  107. doxycycline 100mg over the counter – doxycycline 100mg tablet cost of cialis

  108. I like to spend my free time by scanning various internet resources. Today I came across your website and I found it has some of the most practical and helpful information I’ve seen.

  109. all the time i used to read smaller articles that as well clear
    their motive, and that is also happening with this paragraph which I am reading at this time.

  110. very good post, i certainly love this web site, keep on it

  111. A cool post there mate ! Thank you for posting.

  112. Hello. Great job. I did not expect this on a Wednesday. This is a great story. Thanks!

  113. cialis for sale – buy generic tadalafil 10mg buy modafinil pills

  114. Regards for helping out, superb info.

  115. I love your blog. It looks every informative.

  116. I believe that Litecoin cryptocurrency is the future world payment system. For Litecoin it will be possible to fly into space. But I don’t have the money to buy it myself. Please give me Litecoin.

    My Litecoin address:
    LiFRfuM3jcJVXBLk19gVA8Lh1ukdP7Wngs

  117. buy prednisone 10mg online – deltasone 10mg ca accutane order

  118. Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help
    with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m
    not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share.
    Appreciate it!

  119. Nice weblog here! Additionally your site lots up very fast!
    What web host are you using? Can I am getting your associate link
    in your host? I want my site loaded up as quickly as
    yours lol

  120. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot
    about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but
    instead of that, this is wonderful blog. A fantastic read.
    I will definitely be back.

  121. dark web drug marketplace darkmarkets

  122. drug markets dark web dark markets

  123. order amoxicillin online – purchase amoxicillin online overnight delivery for viagra

  124. It’s in fact very complicated in this active life to listen news on Television, therefore I only use internet for that purpose, and
    get the hottest information.

  125. dark web drug marketplace darkmarkets

  126. I think the admin of this web site is really working hard in support of
    his web site, for the reason that here every stuff is quality based material.

  127. Unquestionably believe that which you said. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly don’t know about. You managed to hit the nail on the head. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  128. order prednisolone 5mg sale – brand prednisolone 10mg cheap generic sildenafil

  129. For most up-to-date news you have to visit world-wide-web and on world-wide-web I found this site as
    a most excellent website for most up-to-date updates.

  130. dark web drug marketplace dark web link

  131. Do you want to be the first? Don’t sit around!
    Useful material here https://www.szukampsychologa.pl/part-time/did-you-begin-golden-crown-casino-code-for-passion-or-money.html
    A lot of interesting things

  132. dark web drug marketplace dark market url

  133. lasix sale – order lasix without prescription ivermectin 12 mg tablet

  134. hi

  135. This blog post is excellent, probably because of how well the subject was developed. I like some of the comments too though I could prefer we all stay on the subject in order add value to the subject!

  136. we’re lucky to have stumbled across your website, it’s really the thing my wife’s friendsMy friends from work are dreaming in search of. The articles on the website is definitely helpful and is going to assist my kids often excellent information. From what I see everone on the site gains a large amount of details about subjects on the site and the other hyper links and information definitely are inherent. I am not on the net very often however as I have some time We are all the way into scouring this type of factual information or stuff likewise the same. Can’t express my gratitude. If you needed some site work like: : We buy used Crossbar 24 pallet racks and pallet shelving near LA

  137. dark web drug marketplace darkmarket link

  138. buy hydroxychloroquine pill – baricitinib oral baricitinib 2mg canada

  139. soma online pharmacy
    canada drugs online review

  140. детские кровати купить https://www.711116.ru

  141. купить кровать ребенку https://711116.ru/

  142. [url=https://regist.su/]Регистрация вагонов может понадобиться при покупке и введение в эксплуатацию нового вагона, передачи в аренду и выводу из неё уже эксплуатируемого, при смене собственности, а также может застать Вас врасплох при необходимости плановой перерегистрации.
    При такой ситуации одним из главных аспектов является скорость формирования необходимого пакета документов для Росжелдора, включая правильность заполнения заявления согласно Регламента и оперативная отправка его в нужные органы власти. Ведь даже незначительная ошибка в отправленных документах является основанием для отказа в регистрации, что приведёт к потере колоссального количества времени и ненужным расходам!
    Всегда можно попробовать вникнуть самостоятельно во все этапы регистрации, оформления документов и их отправки в необходимые ведомства. Но тогда на вашей стороне должны быть
    Опыт
    Знания по оформлению, комплектности и содержанию документов
    Понимание всех этапов регистрации вагона
    Возможность и умение работать с электронным документооборотом
    Или Вы можете просто позвонить нам и мы профессионально справиться с поставленной задачей в кратчайшие сроки![/url]

  143. Do you want to win? Time to start!
    Look at the link http://ttlink.com/hildashoeb
    Latest news

  144. Do you like to win? Don’t stop!
    Visit us https://forum.pedagogionline.ru/index.php?action=profile;u=214933
    Interesting stories

  145. you are really a excellent webmaster. The site loading velocity is incredible.
    It sort of feels that you’re doing any unique trick.
    Also, The contents are masterpiece. you have performed a fantastic activity on this matter!

  146. международные грузоперевозки https://www.zmi2.ru

  147. Thanks for sharing such a fastidious thinking,
    post is pleasant, thats why i have read it fully

  148. Hey! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to
    me. Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be
    bookmarking and checking back often!

  149. Greetings from Idaho! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to
    browse your site on my iphone during lunch break. I love the info you present here and
    can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how quick your blog loaded on my cell phone ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, very good site!

  150. Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.
    Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way, how
    can we communicate?

  151. Свежие статьи о COVID-19 с комментариями терапевта проекта Coronavirus-Control.ru Божко Светланы Игоревны. Весьма любопытный материал!

  152. dark web drug marketplace tor markets

  153. darknet market lists tor market

  154. Do you like to win? Don’t sit around!
    Look here http://xn--um-0ca1ip4qxb5qad7ae50a6ac1587hma98u.disnaikid.com/viewthread.php?tid=548641&extra=
    A lot of useful information

  155. Toyota Crown S130sedan 4.0 AT (1990–1991) – Renault Master 1st generation van 2.1 D L3H1 MT (1984–1992), Pontiac Firebird 3rd generation Trans Am T-Roof targa 2-bit. 3.8 Turbo AT (1989–1990)

  156. dark web drug marketplace tor market links